It shouldn't really surprise anyone that Barack Obama wants to expand the welfare state. For one thing, it is positively Democrat Dogma that more welfare spending is necessarily a good thing. For another, one cannot deny that, by and large, those who are assisted by various welfare programs tend to be Democrat voters.
On the other hand, we should be looking at the results of such spending before we decide to spend more. Are welfare programs enabling independence, or dependency? Are welfare programs reducing, or increasing, the numbers of those in poverty? In short, are welfare programs succeeding, or are they failing?
The first part of the problem, of course, is defining "success." The federal government tends to view a program as a success when it has many subscribers. The more people who are on a given welfare program, the more "successful" the federal government views it. The problem with this paradigm is that welfare programs should be the opposite. After initial subscriptions, the general growth trend in people using the services should be negative. Every year fewer people should qualify for the program- not more.
The other part of the problem determining if a given welfare program meets the definition of success. If you definition is the federal governments, then they're all succeeding beyond your wildest dreams. Under President Barack Obama, more than 1 in 7 Americans are defined as Living in Poverty; that's the most in nearly twenty years. If, on the other hand, you definition of success is that fewer people need services, and the ones who need them need fewer, it is a miserable failure.
It should be obvious to anyone who wishes to help the poor stop being poor that the modern welfare state is an abject failure. Increased rolls show increased instances. Increased spending indicate increased dependency. If our goal is to assist those who are poor to elevate themselves out of poverty, we're obviously doing something wrong.
Yet, rather than reevaluate the efforts of the federal government, Democrats in general, and Barack Obama in particular, insist that increased spending and enrollment are the answer. Rather than check their theories against the test results of reality, they insist that reality must be wrong. Instead of deciding that something is wrong, and attempting a different tactic, the Democrats propose more of the same, and accuse Conservatives of being inhumane when we disagree.
Yes, Barack Obama is the Food Stamps President. Not because he cares about the poor, but because his party has painted itself into a corner. Any admission that they've been wrong for the last 50 years would set them back, politically speaking, for decades to come. Continuing on the same course dooms generations of Americans to poverty which could be avoided.
Monday, July 23, 2012
The Growing Police State: Who's Watching You? Edition
On Thursday, in testimony to Congress, it was revealed that over 100 "Federal, State, and Local" government "entities" have had authorization from the Federal Aviation Administration to conduct unmanned surveillance of the Domestic US Population. According to House Homeland Security Oversight Subcommittee Chairman Michael McCaul, there are around 200 active Authorizations covering over 100 entities. His quote: "We are now on the edge of a new horizon: using unmanned aerial systems within the homeland."
I've covered before why this should be so troublesome. Now it looks like, by the time we were even informed that government was looking into the possibility, they'd already been doing it for some time. This should terrify any free people. The Government has neither the right, nor the power, to spy on its own citizens without a warrant which specifically details the subjects and objects of the investigation. Simply flying a drone to see what can be seen is a gross violation of the 4th Amendment to the US Constitution. It is the move of a dictatorial regime more interested in keeping the domestic populace in line than in serving them and governing wisely.
Once again, I find myself compelled to appeal to the States. The Federal Government obviously acknowledges no limits to its own authority. If any limits are to exist, the States must set them and enforce them. The States must say, "Not in my State, you don't. Not over my residents."
I've covered before why this should be so troublesome. Now it looks like, by the time we were even informed that government was looking into the possibility, they'd already been doing it for some time. This should terrify any free people. The Government has neither the right, nor the power, to spy on its own citizens without a warrant which specifically details the subjects and objects of the investigation. Simply flying a drone to see what can be seen is a gross violation of the 4th Amendment to the US Constitution. It is the move of a dictatorial regime more interested in keeping the domestic populace in line than in serving them and governing wisely.
Once again, I find myself compelled to appeal to the States. The Federal Government obviously acknowledges no limits to its own authority. If any limits are to exist, the States must set them and enforce them. The States must say, "Not in my State, you don't. Not over my residents."
Friday, July 20, 2012
Mourning in America
I would like to extend my condolences to those families and friends of the (last number I heard) 15 murdered in a Colorado theater early this morning. Whatever the talking heads and pundits say, there is no reason for this monstrosity beyond the fact the shooter was a monster. Any discussion of "why" simply serves to take the emphasis off the victims, both dead and the survivors, and lessens their suffering.
I pray that God will grant them peace and comfort.
I pray that God will grant them peace and comfort.
Thursday, July 19, 2012
The Growing Police State: Mileage Tax Edition
The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized. -US Constitution, Amendment IV
What is it about the Constitution that these people don't understand? Regardless of the "incorporation" doctrine (which was made up by the Supreme Court), the 4th Amendment refers to a Right of the People. That is, no authority in the US is allowed to take it away (see also: Amendments 9 & 10).
In California, specifically around the San Francisco Bay area, law makers want to track your car via GPS to see how many miles you drive, and tax you accordingly. Now, I understand why, really. Electric, or even just hybrid, cars really do use less gasoline (even if the savings doesn't make up the price difference for the car) and gasoline taxes are a major part of the transportation budget. I get that. I understand its a problem that needs to be addressed. But you do not address it by violating the constitution, and my right to be secure in my person, home, papers, and effects supercedes the government's right to tax me based on how much I drive.
The Government doesn't get to know where I go and what I do. Not without a warrant issued only "upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized." That means they don't get to read my GPS to see how far I've traveled.
And that avoids the bad acting that is sure to go on: things like taxing people for miles driven out of state, using these records (because they're already state records) as evidence in criminal trials, and so forth. I don't even have to go there because the idea itself is clearly ludicrous.
There are answers to the electric / hybrid-car problem. Personally, I'd love to see the gas tax done away with entirely, and have that revenue generated some other way. Perhaps as a calculated amount added to your yearly registration fee or something (not sure how that would work out, though). The specific answer does not matter, however: this is clearly government over-reach and should be vociferously opposed.
Fast and Furious: Consequences for Whistleblowing
From the Washington Guardian comes this rather chilling piece. It seems the federal prosecutor who was tasked with reforming the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives isn't so interested in reforming the organization as he is interested in people not blowing the whistle.
In a video to ATF Employees, he states, "Choices and consequences means simply that if you make poor choices, that if you don't abide by the rules, that if you don't respect the chain of command, if you don't find the appropriate way to raise your concerns to your leadership, there will be consequences."
How this can be perceived as anything other than a threat to silence whistle-blowers is beyond me. The Acting Director, B. Todd Jones, was brought in specifically to rehabilitate ATF in the wake of the Fast and Furious Scandal (required note: Watergate did not have a body count). The only reason we know about Fast and Furious is whistle-blowers who did not "find the appropriate way to raise [their] concerns..."
In any organization, employees need someone who is outside their "chain of command," to whom they can take complaints. Whatever the law says, retaliation is real, and employees who have legitimate complaints need a way to raise those complaints without risking reprisals. This is especially true when your employer is a government agency and your "complaint" is that you believe your agency is conducting an act of war against an allied foreign power.
These comments show that ATF not only has not learned this lesson, but is trying desperately to avoid it.
Watergate did not have a body count.
Fast and Furious was an Act of War against an allied foreign power.
In a video to ATF Employees, he states, "Choices and consequences means simply that if you make poor choices, that if you don't abide by the rules, that if you don't respect the chain of command, if you don't find the appropriate way to raise your concerns to your leadership, there will be consequences."
How this can be perceived as anything other than a threat to silence whistle-blowers is beyond me. The Acting Director, B. Todd Jones, was brought in specifically to rehabilitate ATF in the wake of the Fast and Furious Scandal (required note: Watergate did not have a body count). The only reason we know about Fast and Furious is whistle-blowers who did not "find the appropriate way to raise [their] concerns..."
In any organization, employees need someone who is outside their "chain of command," to whom they can take complaints. Whatever the law says, retaliation is real, and employees who have legitimate complaints need a way to raise those complaints without risking reprisals. This is especially true when your employer is a government agency and your "complaint" is that you believe your agency is conducting an act of war against an allied foreign power.
These comments show that ATF not only has not learned this lesson, but is trying desperately to avoid it.
Watergate did not have a body count.
Fast and Furious was an Act of War against an allied foreign power.
On Communism vs Capitalism
Over at the AoSHQ (linked in my side bar, as always) we got to having a discussion about how Communism has always failed everywhere, and everywhen, it has been tried. I thought I'd share my thoughts here for any readers who don't go there.
First off, I should point out that I know of two instances where a group of people tried to practice "True" Communism- what previously was called "Utopian Communism." That is, I know, from my own research and education, about two instances where everyone in a relatively small group really submitted themselves for the benefit of the group and where the group punished or exiled the small number of people who did not. There may be others, but the two I know of are 1st Century AD Christians in Jerusalem, and the Reunion Colony in Texas where a portion of Dallas now sits.
This is important, because these two instance provide anecdotal evidence that, even if communists were right about human nature (they're not, but we'll get to that later), the world itself works in such a way that communism will fail. See, in both cases, because of their communist societies, no one had any extra. Those who had extra had already shared with those who did not. That's a good and noble thing, but it's short sighted (as both groups found out). First Century Jewish Christians had to give up their communist model when a drought and famine devastated the Middle East just a couple of years after Christ's ascension. Because they had all shared everything equally, no one had any reserves to see them through the hard times. They were reduced to surviving based on gifts from other Christians around the world. The Reunion Colony did not have that support structure, so when they suffered a massive crop failure, the colony failed.
In neither case was human action to "blame," for the failure of communism. The nature of communism itself makes it unlikely that there will ever be reserves of anything, so when acts of nature cause shortages, there's no way to make it up. Weather and natural occurrences make communism unworkable.
What is also important in both of these models is that neither lasted very long, but they had problems from the get-go. The Christians, quite famously, had Ananias and Sapphira. The Reunion Colony had other bad actors. Had they continued as communist communities, these would have become more frequent and more magnified.
But, you see, we don't need these examples. Virtually every school day, somewhere in America, we have another perfect microcosm of the inherent problems with Communism. Group Projects. You remember group projects, right? You teacher probably assigned the group, though if you were lucky you got to pick the group so you could be with your friends. Then you were given an assignment on which everyone was supposed to work. How many times did it work out that way? In my entire school career, I recall twice- and both times I was grouped with my friends, and both times we were purposely subversive. Yes, I was that way in High School, too.
In most cases, one or two people actually do all the work while the others, either out of incompetence or laziness, simply enjoy the fruits of the others' labor. This happened far more often than actual group work, and the reasons are simple. In most groups, you have one or two kids who care about their grades enough that the other kids know they'll drag the project over the finish line. With only one or two of them working on it, it may only get a B or C, but that's passing, and that's enough for the others. For their part, the hard-working kids know that if they don't do it, the best grade they can hope for is a C as everyone else phones it in, so they pick up that work because they do care about their own grades.
Both of these explain why communism will not, cannot, work. First, because human nature is such that we are not communal by nature. Every person thinks of themselves first. Second, because nature itself requires that humans not be communal- communal living has less ability to forecast and plan for future conditions than the "greedy" or "selfish" capitalistic system.
In a capitalistic system, hundreds, thousands, millions, or even billions of people each work for their own direct good. They each try to plan for the future- so when one gets it wrong, there are others who got it right and then have the resources to support the one who got it wrong. But this system, to operate effectively, requires that everyone work. It requires that society itself not assist anyone, but rather that it encourage individuals to assist each other.
In pure theory (it would never happen in the real world) a pure capitalist society, with each person working for his or her own direct good; where government ensured the rules were easy to understand and applied equally to all; where each person reaped the rewards of hard work, and dealt with the consequences of failure: in that purely theoretical world, a capitalist society would be every bit as "Utopian" as any communist society could ever dream.
In the real world, Capitalism leads to more freedom, more wealth- even at the "poverty" level- and more access to opportunity and even to justice than Communism ever will. As flawed as it is, Capitalism is more grounded in the real world, and therefore a much better system than communism or socialism.
First off, I should point out that I know of two instances where a group of people tried to practice "True" Communism- what previously was called "Utopian Communism." That is, I know, from my own research and education, about two instances where everyone in a relatively small group really submitted themselves for the benefit of the group and where the group punished or exiled the small number of people who did not. There may be others, but the two I know of are 1st Century AD Christians in Jerusalem, and the Reunion Colony in Texas where a portion of Dallas now sits.
This is important, because these two instance provide anecdotal evidence that, even if communists were right about human nature (they're not, but we'll get to that later), the world itself works in such a way that communism will fail. See, in both cases, because of their communist societies, no one had any extra. Those who had extra had already shared with those who did not. That's a good and noble thing, but it's short sighted (as both groups found out). First Century Jewish Christians had to give up their communist model when a drought and famine devastated the Middle East just a couple of years after Christ's ascension. Because they had all shared everything equally, no one had any reserves to see them through the hard times. They were reduced to surviving based on gifts from other Christians around the world. The Reunion Colony did not have that support structure, so when they suffered a massive crop failure, the colony failed.
In neither case was human action to "blame," for the failure of communism. The nature of communism itself makes it unlikely that there will ever be reserves of anything, so when acts of nature cause shortages, there's no way to make it up. Weather and natural occurrences make communism unworkable.
What is also important in both of these models is that neither lasted very long, but they had problems from the get-go. The Christians, quite famously, had Ananias and Sapphira. The Reunion Colony had other bad actors. Had they continued as communist communities, these would have become more frequent and more magnified.
But, you see, we don't need these examples. Virtually every school day, somewhere in America, we have another perfect microcosm of the inherent problems with Communism. Group Projects. You remember group projects, right? You teacher probably assigned the group, though if you were lucky you got to pick the group so you could be with your friends. Then you were given an assignment on which everyone was supposed to work. How many times did it work out that way? In my entire school career, I recall twice- and both times I was grouped with my friends, and both times we were purposely subversive. Yes, I was that way in High School, too.
In most cases, one or two people actually do all the work while the others, either out of incompetence or laziness, simply enjoy the fruits of the others' labor. This happened far more often than actual group work, and the reasons are simple. In most groups, you have one or two kids who care about their grades enough that the other kids know they'll drag the project over the finish line. With only one or two of them working on it, it may only get a B or C, but that's passing, and that's enough for the others. For their part, the hard-working kids know that if they don't do it, the best grade they can hope for is a C as everyone else phones it in, so they pick up that work because they do care about their own grades.
Both of these explain why communism will not, cannot, work. First, because human nature is such that we are not communal by nature. Every person thinks of themselves first. Second, because nature itself requires that humans not be communal- communal living has less ability to forecast and plan for future conditions than the "greedy" or "selfish" capitalistic system.
In a capitalistic system, hundreds, thousands, millions, or even billions of people each work for their own direct good. They each try to plan for the future- so when one gets it wrong, there are others who got it right and then have the resources to support the one who got it wrong. But this system, to operate effectively, requires that everyone work. It requires that society itself not assist anyone, but rather that it encourage individuals to assist each other.
In pure theory (it would never happen in the real world) a pure capitalist society, with each person working for his or her own direct good; where government ensured the rules were easy to understand and applied equally to all; where each person reaped the rewards of hard work, and dealt with the consequences of failure: in that purely theoretical world, a capitalist society would be every bit as "Utopian" as any communist society could ever dream.
In the real world, Capitalism leads to more freedom, more wealth- even at the "poverty" level- and more access to opportunity and even to justice than Communism ever will. As flawed as it is, Capitalism is more grounded in the real world, and therefore a much better system than communism or socialism.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
