Over at the HQ for the last little while, we've been talking about Rebranding the Republican Party (or the Conservative movement- sometimes the two get conflated when they shouldn't). I've commented a lot over there, but I wanted to use this space to get a bunch of ideas all in one place.
First off, as I see it, the Republican Party and the Conservative Movement are not the same thing. I am a Conservative. Until and unless the Republican Party can prove to me that they are also Conservative, I am not a Republican (even though I'll probably vote "R" much more often than "L" for the moment). Now, Many Republicans are Conservative, and I would venture that most Conservatives are Republican, but not all Republicans are Conservatives, and a goodly number of Conservatives vote Libertarian (I cannot believe anyone who is conservative could vote Democrat in good conscience).
To that end, it is the Conservative Movement that I will be discussing.
So, if you're ready to come along for the ride, take a look under the fold.
Showing posts with label Message. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Message. Show all posts
Monday, March 18, 2013
Thursday, February 14, 2013
And This is why Rick Perry Didn't Woo The Media
In Rick Perry's 2010 run against Bill White, he fairly scandalized the Texas Media by not once agreeing to sit down with the various Newspaper editorial boards to "seek their endorsement." When asked about it, he said it was because he knew they weren't going to endorse him anyway, so why bother? He was excoriated and ridiculed. And won by (if I recall) ~7 percentage points.
And he was right to eschew the Texas Media, beyond what was absolutely necessary to get his message out. Here's a contemporary example of what he was dealing with:
Headline: "Perry Ending Calif. Trip Empty Handed- So Far."
It's also important to recognized that "So Far" is on a second line. Note the tone of the headline (which is all most people will read or remember): "That loser Rick Perry who thought he could compete when to California to woo businesses and came back empty handed. Ha!"
Never mind the fact that a business, even a small business, can't just decide to move in 3 days. Small business people are exceptional, but they aren't miracle workers. Larger companies take even longer just to make up their minds to move.
Never mind that Texas has already been successful in either wooing businesses away from California all together, or at least into expanding into Texas.
Never mind that apparently Rick Perry was in Governor Brown's head enough, that Brown thought he had to insult Rick Perry, instead of sticking up for his own state's business climate.
Now, all of that is of interest to me, here in Texas. Why should it interest you outside of Texas?
Texas is one of the most conservative States in the Nation. We have plenty of doozies, but our local Democrats tend to be only flirting with insanity, rather than being actually insane. Rick Perry himself was once a Democrat, back when "Conservative" and "Democrat" went together without hysterical laughter. Our news organizations tend to reflect that. Even the very liberal Dallas Morning News can't stomach some of the more blatant bias in, for instance, the New York Times. If a Republican Governor in a Republican State knows that he can count on the State (and local) Media machines to be hostile, then it's time our national Republicans learned the lesson, too.
John Boehner: MSNBC is not your friend.
Mitch McConnel: The New York Times will never like you.
John McCain: ABC, CBS, and NBC will be glad to use you against other Republicans, but they will never, ever support you.
National Republicans need to take a page out of Rick Perry's book (actually, they need to take several, but one hopeless battle at a time) and start treating the National Media as the Hostile, if not outright Antagonistic actors they are.
And he was right to eschew the Texas Media, beyond what was absolutely necessary to get his message out. Here's a contemporary example of what he was dealing with:
Headline: "Perry Ending Calif. Trip Empty Handed- So Far."
It's also important to recognized that "So Far" is on a second line. Note the tone of the headline (which is all most people will read or remember): "That loser Rick Perry who thought he could compete when to California to woo businesses and came back empty handed. Ha!"
Never mind the fact that a business, even a small business, can't just decide to move in 3 days. Small business people are exceptional, but they aren't miracle workers. Larger companies take even longer just to make up their minds to move.
Never mind that Texas has already been successful in either wooing businesses away from California all together, or at least into expanding into Texas.
Never mind that apparently Rick Perry was in Governor Brown's head enough, that Brown thought he had to insult Rick Perry, instead of sticking up for his own state's business climate.
Now, all of that is of interest to me, here in Texas. Why should it interest you outside of Texas?
Texas is one of the most conservative States in the Nation. We have plenty of doozies, but our local Democrats tend to be only flirting with insanity, rather than being actually insane. Rick Perry himself was once a Democrat, back when "Conservative" and "Democrat" went together without hysterical laughter. Our news organizations tend to reflect that. Even the very liberal Dallas Morning News can't stomach some of the more blatant bias in, for instance, the New York Times. If a Republican Governor in a Republican State knows that he can count on the State (and local) Media machines to be hostile, then it's time our national Republicans learned the lesson, too.
John Boehner: MSNBC is not your friend.
Mitch McConnel: The New York Times will never like you.
John McCain: ABC, CBS, and NBC will be glad to use you against other Republicans, but they will never, ever support you.
National Republicans need to take a page out of Rick Perry's book (actually, they need to take several, but one hopeless battle at a time) and start treating the National Media as the Hostile, if not outright Antagonistic actors they are.
Tuesday, January 22, 2013
Causal Confusion
You've probably heard or seen commercials from the National Association of Realtors about "the benefits of home ownership." These include better grades for kids, more cohesive family units, higher employment, and unicorns (I think I made that last one up). To hear them tell it, if everyone just bought a house, everything would be better.
Even granting them the best of motives, this is irresponsible advertising and giving people false expectations. And I don't grant them the best of motives.
You see, the premise of these commercials is a fallacious conflation of causal relationships. For my Liberal readers: it gets cause and effect backwards.
In the early days of my blog, I addressed it this way: frugality fosters wealth, not the other way around. You see, the fact is that couples who are committed to each other and their children, who work hard and save money, and who have the personal habits associated with those things will tend to own homes. It is not owning the home that makes them committed and hard working. Exactly the opposite, it's the commitment and hard work that makes them good candidates for home ownership.
Unfortunately, this disease does not simply effect the NAR. It seems to have spread everywhere. Colleges tell you that getting a degree will enhance your prospects, when the truth is (especially in this age of degrees in Underwater Basket Weaving), that the kind of people who are likely to be successful are the same ones who will tend to get college degrees. More over, they will tend to get STEM degrees, not Liberal Arts degrees.
This really gets to the heart of our "because I deserve it!" society. We have ceased being a society of personal responsibility and liberty- the society that built this nation into the greatest on earth- and have become a society of "steps to success" and "easy money." Our grandparents and great-grandparents did not believe that there were certain steps that would lead to wealth and prosperity. Rather they realized that accomplishing certain goals would require certain steps. Our parents, for various reasons, began getting that backward, and they imparted that to my generation.
Now, people believe that if they go to college, they are owed a job when they graduate. They believe that once they sign to purchase a house, they are owed prosperity and a good school and a job.
It's completely backwards, and it will change. The only question is if it will change because we, as a society, set out to change it, or if it will change because the gods of the copy-book headings will force it on us.
Even granting them the best of motives, this is irresponsible advertising and giving people false expectations. And I don't grant them the best of motives.
You see, the premise of these commercials is a fallacious conflation of causal relationships. For my Liberal readers: it gets cause and effect backwards.
In the early days of my blog, I addressed it this way: frugality fosters wealth, not the other way around. You see, the fact is that couples who are committed to each other and their children, who work hard and save money, and who have the personal habits associated with those things will tend to own homes. It is not owning the home that makes them committed and hard working. Exactly the opposite, it's the commitment and hard work that makes them good candidates for home ownership.
Unfortunately, this disease does not simply effect the NAR. It seems to have spread everywhere. Colleges tell you that getting a degree will enhance your prospects, when the truth is (especially in this age of degrees in Underwater Basket Weaving), that the kind of people who are likely to be successful are the same ones who will tend to get college degrees. More over, they will tend to get STEM degrees, not Liberal Arts degrees.
This really gets to the heart of our "because I deserve it!" society. We have ceased being a society of personal responsibility and liberty- the society that built this nation into the greatest on earth- and have become a society of "steps to success" and "easy money." Our grandparents and great-grandparents did not believe that there were certain steps that would lead to wealth and prosperity. Rather they realized that accomplishing certain goals would require certain steps. Our parents, for various reasons, began getting that backward, and they imparted that to my generation.
Now, people believe that if they go to college, they are owed a job when they graduate. They believe that once they sign to purchase a house, they are owed prosperity and a good school and a job.
It's completely backwards, and it will change. The only question is if it will change because we, as a society, set out to change it, or if it will change because the gods of the copy-book headings will force it on us.
Monday, December 10, 2012
GOP Communication Classes?
On the CBS morning show "This Morning" Dick Armey suggested that much of the Republican plight in the November election stemmed from candidates who "said some dumb things." He believes the Republican Party needs to educate candidates on how to avoid saying such dumb things. With due respect to former Leader Armey, this is hogwash. No one should need to be "educated" so that they don't say that the body has rape-sensing hormones that prevent pregnancy, or that rape is "a blessing." In fact, no one did say the latter, and the former was at least based on a scientific hypothesis. The hypothesis has been soundly debunked, but it was an actually proffered hypothesis once.
No, the Republican Party needs to figure out that the Tea Party isn't going anywhere, and join forces. If the Republican party would partner with local tea party groups to help vet candidates, and put forward candidates who are both acceptable to grass-roots conservatives and unlikely to say "dumb things" in the first place, then we'd be in a better position. The problem with that is that the Tea Party represents opposition to much of what is wrong with the Republican Party, and the Republican Party doesn't like to admit that it has things wrong with it.
Until the local Tea Parties are accepted as legitimate partners with the Republicans, the two will work to cross purposes and Democrats will continue to be elected. In those instances when Republicans have embraced the Tea Party, they have experience success. Take a look at the Texas Congressional Delegation, for instance. Scott Brown was elected on Tea Party sentiment. He was not re-elected because he tried to out-Democrat the Democrat.
Communication is, indeed, an issue. It probably did cost us a couple of otherwise safe seats. But rather than focus on the window-dressing, the Republican Party needs to partner with grass-roots groups to help select men and women who are already able purveyors of the Conservative Message.
No, the Republican Party needs to figure out that the Tea Party isn't going anywhere, and join forces. If the Republican party would partner with local tea party groups to help vet candidates, and put forward candidates who are both acceptable to grass-roots conservatives and unlikely to say "dumb things" in the first place, then we'd be in a better position. The problem with that is that the Tea Party represents opposition to much of what is wrong with the Republican Party, and the Republican Party doesn't like to admit that it has things wrong with it.
Until the local Tea Parties are accepted as legitimate partners with the Republicans, the two will work to cross purposes and Democrats will continue to be elected. In those instances when Republicans have embraced the Tea Party, they have experience success. Take a look at the Texas Congressional Delegation, for instance. Scott Brown was elected on Tea Party sentiment. He was not re-elected because he tried to out-Democrat the Democrat.
Communication is, indeed, an issue. It probably did cost us a couple of otherwise safe seats. But rather than focus on the window-dressing, the Republican Party needs to partner with grass-roots groups to help select men and women who are already able purveyors of the Conservative Message.
Friday, December 7, 2012
#CultureWar: Madison Rising
Welcome to the first in a new post category for Dedicated Tenther. #CultureWar will focus on Conservatives in the trenches in the Culture War. Mostly this will focus on music, because that's where we're best represented.
If you have tips about any #CultureWar soldiers (that would be: entertainers who are conservative, and not shy about it) please send them my way.
****
Madison Rising is a Conservative Rock (yes, apparently this is a genre) band. You've probably heard or seen their version of the Star Spangled Banner. That's only the tip of their rock and roll iceberg. You can buy their music (please do) via the iTunes store or CD Baby, or you can just donate to the band via Pay-Pal (but why, when they're music is so good?).
I've listened to some of their music, and I have to say it's good. This is not a case of a band receiving praise because they're trying to fill a niche I see needs to be filled, but because they fill it well. Just as conservatives can listen to liberal weenies like (insert band here) and just enjoy the music, anyone can just listen to Madison Rising for some good hard rock and roll.
Their Star Spangled Banner is below the fold. Go check 'em out and send them some of your coin.
If you have tips about any #CultureWar soldiers (that would be: entertainers who are conservative, and not shy about it) please send them my way.
****
Madison Rising is a Conservative Rock (yes, apparently this is a genre) band. You've probably heard or seen their version of the Star Spangled Banner. That's only the tip of their rock and roll iceberg. You can buy their music (please do) via the iTunes store or CD Baby, or you can just donate to the band via Pay-Pal (but why, when they're music is so good?).
I've listened to some of their music, and I have to say it's good. This is not a case of a band receiving praise because they're trying to fill a niche I see needs to be filled, but because they fill it well. Just as conservatives can listen to liberal weenies like (insert band here) and just enjoy the music, anyone can just listen to Madison Rising for some good hard rock and roll.
Their Star Spangled Banner is below the fold. Go check 'em out and send them some of your coin.
Thursday, December 6, 2012
The Politics of Conflict
Going back to 1972, at least, a good rule of thumb is that Republicans will lose low turnout elections. High turnout elections have tended towards Republicans, but the reason for the high turnout matters. For instance, Clinton's election in 1992 was a very high turnout, but the semi-spoiler of Ross Perot gave it to the Democrat. Barack Obama's election in 2008 was very high turnout, as people turned out to vote for the First Black President. However, both the 96 and 2012 elections had many fewer votes, relative to the prior cycle.
So it seems that the Republicans' best chance to win elections is to encourage high turnout. High turnout gives Republicans a much better chance of winning than low turnout. So the question becomes, "how do we encourage high turn out?"
Here, I have a suggestion. I do not remember the 1980 and 1984 elections at all. I do recall the 1988 election some (c'mon, I was 8), and I remember 92 and on pretty well. Basing this guess on what I've heard about the Reagan elections, I feel fairly safe in making the suggestion. Conflict wins elections for Republicans.
Reagan did not just run against Carter in 1980, he ran against the idea of Carter as well. That is, he clearly defined two teams, and then asked American voters to join one. People voted in droves, and mostly chose Reagan's team. When Bush 41 ran in 1988, he drew similar team lines. "Read my lips, no new taxes." Contrariwise, Bush 41 lost to Clinton in 92 because he'd reneged on that "no new taxes" pledge, and people could see no difference between the two. The guy who tried to draw clear team lines was Ross Perot, who didn't have the needed infrastructure to win. Bush 44 barely won over Al Gore. The reason that election was so close was, once again, the lines between the two "teams" were blurred.
Of note here is that I'm using the term "team" on purpose. This isn't about parties. One thing Ross Perot's runs in 92 and 96 prove is that there are certain partisans who will always vote for their party. Those aren't the ones who are choosing a team in each election. The teams are for those who are less partisan. Maybe they normally vote R or D, but they can be persuaded. Maybe they don't normally vote at all.
So how do we draw those team lines? We use conflict. Reagan was good at doing this affably, but the conflict needs to exist. Let's take a couple of looks at popular culture to make the point.
American wrestling, currently existing as the WWE, used to be a very minor niche of entertainment, and just didn't have a following. That all changed decades ago, when someone- I'm not sure any but those who were following then even remembers who- decided to make the show more exciting. How was that done? He took the persona of the bad guy. Now, audiences had someone to root against (him) and, by extension, someone to root for. To this day, the WWE uses this formula, and experiences great commercial success. Professional boxing is trying to do the same thing through building up and promoting rivalries.
American Idol burst onto the scene 11 years ago. From the beginning it was wildly popular. However, the 2011 season was weak, and the 2012 season was weaker. The show is flailing trying to maintain its power. What changed? Simon Cowell left. Simon Cowell, the acerbic Brit and primary judge, was the primary draw for the show. Why? Because he created conflict. While everyone else was heaping praise on contestants, Simon would make up some off-the-wall simile to say "that sucked." It drove conflict on the judging panel, and it drove conflict with the contestants. You could root for or against Simon, and therefore for or against specific contestants or the other judges. With him gone, there is no conflict. Randy has tried to fill his shoes by being a little more honest with the contestants, but he doesn't drive conflict. He's too conciliatory when he's telling someone they suck. So Idol is in decline.
It is this last part that I think is important. No one who was paying attention could seriously believe that Mitt Romney and the SCOAMT had any positions really in common. There was disagreement. However, Mitt Romney seemed to run from conflict. Mere disagreement will not suffice; a clear conflict, a rivalry is necessary. It gets people excited and encourages them to pick a side. Instead, people didn't see that there were sides to pick, and so people stayed home.
If Republicans want to win the White House in 2016 (assuming The Great Collapse has not already occurred), they must embrace conflict. When the Democrat says, "We need to raise revenue," the Republican needs to respond "No, we don't." Direct contradiction is the most basic form of conflict. It gets people's attention. Imagine if, during the debates, SCOAMT had said, "...and so I'm proposing to raise revenue by blah, blah..." and Romney had immediately rejoined, "Raise revenue? Don't you mean raise taxes? Please, Mr. President, be honest with the American people. And while we're being honest; we don't have a problem with revenue, we have a problem with spending."
That's a clear line. That creates Team Raise Taxes and Team Cut Spending. On item after item Romney could have chosen to engage in conflict, and therefore give the American People some one to root for and someone to root against. Had he done so, maybe we'd be talking about President Elect Romney today.
So it seems that the Republicans' best chance to win elections is to encourage high turnout. High turnout gives Republicans a much better chance of winning than low turnout. So the question becomes, "how do we encourage high turn out?"
Here, I have a suggestion. I do not remember the 1980 and 1984 elections at all. I do recall the 1988 election some (c'mon, I was 8), and I remember 92 and on pretty well. Basing this guess on what I've heard about the Reagan elections, I feel fairly safe in making the suggestion. Conflict wins elections for Republicans.
Reagan did not just run against Carter in 1980, he ran against the idea of Carter as well. That is, he clearly defined two teams, and then asked American voters to join one. People voted in droves, and mostly chose Reagan's team. When Bush 41 ran in 1988, he drew similar team lines. "Read my lips, no new taxes." Contrariwise, Bush 41 lost to Clinton in 92 because he'd reneged on that "no new taxes" pledge, and people could see no difference between the two. The guy who tried to draw clear team lines was Ross Perot, who didn't have the needed infrastructure to win. Bush 44 barely won over Al Gore. The reason that election was so close was, once again, the lines between the two "teams" were blurred.
Of note here is that I'm using the term "team" on purpose. This isn't about parties. One thing Ross Perot's runs in 92 and 96 prove is that there are certain partisans who will always vote for their party. Those aren't the ones who are choosing a team in each election. The teams are for those who are less partisan. Maybe they normally vote R or D, but they can be persuaded. Maybe they don't normally vote at all.
So how do we draw those team lines? We use conflict. Reagan was good at doing this affably, but the conflict needs to exist. Let's take a couple of looks at popular culture to make the point.
American wrestling, currently existing as the WWE, used to be a very minor niche of entertainment, and just didn't have a following. That all changed decades ago, when someone- I'm not sure any but those who were following then even remembers who- decided to make the show more exciting. How was that done? He took the persona of the bad guy. Now, audiences had someone to root against (him) and, by extension, someone to root for. To this day, the WWE uses this formula, and experiences great commercial success. Professional boxing is trying to do the same thing through building up and promoting rivalries.
American Idol burst onto the scene 11 years ago. From the beginning it was wildly popular. However, the 2011 season was weak, and the 2012 season was weaker. The show is flailing trying to maintain its power. What changed? Simon Cowell left. Simon Cowell, the acerbic Brit and primary judge, was the primary draw for the show. Why? Because he created conflict. While everyone else was heaping praise on contestants, Simon would make up some off-the-wall simile to say "that sucked." It drove conflict on the judging panel, and it drove conflict with the contestants. You could root for or against Simon, and therefore for or against specific contestants or the other judges. With him gone, there is no conflict. Randy has tried to fill his shoes by being a little more honest with the contestants, but he doesn't drive conflict. He's too conciliatory when he's telling someone they suck. So Idol is in decline.
It is this last part that I think is important. No one who was paying attention could seriously believe that Mitt Romney and the SCOAMT had any positions really in common. There was disagreement. However, Mitt Romney seemed to run from conflict. Mere disagreement will not suffice; a clear conflict, a rivalry is necessary. It gets people excited and encourages them to pick a side. Instead, people didn't see that there were sides to pick, and so people stayed home.
If Republicans want to win the White House in 2016 (assuming The Great Collapse has not already occurred), they must embrace conflict. When the Democrat says, "We need to raise revenue," the Republican needs to respond "No, we don't." Direct contradiction is the most basic form of conflict. It gets people's attention. Imagine if, during the debates, SCOAMT had said, "...and so I'm proposing to raise revenue by blah, blah..." and Romney had immediately rejoined, "Raise revenue? Don't you mean raise taxes? Please, Mr. President, be honest with the American people. And while we're being honest; we don't have a problem with revenue, we have a problem with spending."
That's a clear line. That creates Team Raise Taxes and Team Cut Spending. On item after item Romney could have chosen to engage in conflict, and therefore give the American People some one to root for and someone to root against. Had he done so, maybe we'd be talking about President Elect Romney today.
Monday, November 19, 2012
Surrender, Retreat, or Attack?
I mentioned this over in the comments at the Ace of Spades HQ (link in sidebar), but thought I would expand on it here.
After the devastating (morally, if not mathematically) loss by Mitt Romney to Barack Obama in the November 6th election, Republican recriminations have been thicker than flies on a carcass. When boiled down, Republicans (and Conservatives; the two do not completely overlap) seem to fall into one of three camps.
The retreat group is also made up of two different groups, though I think they largely agree on the ultimate goal, and just disagree tactically. The first of these groups agrees that the collapse is inevitable (and, indeed, may also be in the "let it burn" category), and says that the correct answer is to look to your own family, and do everything you can to prepare for the collapse. Once the collapse then comes, the argument goes, "we" will survive in much better shape to guide whatever rises from the ashes. The second group believes in a Mass Conservative Migration. This group believes that conservatives from irredeemably Blue States should move to Red (or even swing) States and build a very strong Conservative base in those areas. They do not believe the collapse is inevitable.
The final group seems also be made up of two groups. The first group says that we should attack the Democrats on everything. We should fight the fiscal cliff fight, for example, demanding everything we want, and be just as willing to go over the fiscal cliff as the Democrats are. The second group recommends what I've heard described as the Red Diaspora. This would be the reverse of the Mass Conservative Migration. Instead of Conservatives in Blue States moving to Red States, Conservatives in Red States would move to Blue States, trying to make them into Swing States.
The only group I'm sure I disagree with is the "attack" group. I do not believe we currently have the resources to make either of those strategies work. For the political opposition line to work, I think we would need a strong Conservative leader. Instead we have John Boehner. I don't think the risk of turning reliably Red States into swing (or worse: Blue) States is worth the relatively minor gains we would see from Diaspora.
I find myself at least in partial agreement with both "Let it Burn" (surrender and retreat varieties) and with the Mass Conservative Migration retreat groups. You might call these "strategic retreats." They are falling back to stronger positions to reorganize and strengthen our "army."
Fill the comments with your thoughts. I think this is of vital importance to decide before local elections next year.
After the devastating (morally, if not mathematically) loss by Mitt Romney to Barack Obama in the November 6th election, Republican recriminations have been thicker than flies on a carcass. When boiled down, Republicans (and Conservatives; the two do not completely overlap) seem to fall into one of three camps.
- Surrender
- Retreat
- Attack
The retreat group is also made up of two different groups, though I think they largely agree on the ultimate goal, and just disagree tactically. The first of these groups agrees that the collapse is inevitable (and, indeed, may also be in the "let it burn" category), and says that the correct answer is to look to your own family, and do everything you can to prepare for the collapse. Once the collapse then comes, the argument goes, "we" will survive in much better shape to guide whatever rises from the ashes. The second group believes in a Mass Conservative Migration. This group believes that conservatives from irredeemably Blue States should move to Red (or even swing) States and build a very strong Conservative base in those areas. They do not believe the collapse is inevitable.
The final group seems also be made up of two groups. The first group says that we should attack the Democrats on everything. We should fight the fiscal cliff fight, for example, demanding everything we want, and be just as willing to go over the fiscal cliff as the Democrats are. The second group recommends what I've heard described as the Red Diaspora. This would be the reverse of the Mass Conservative Migration. Instead of Conservatives in Blue States moving to Red States, Conservatives in Red States would move to Blue States, trying to make them into Swing States.
The only group I'm sure I disagree with is the "attack" group. I do not believe we currently have the resources to make either of those strategies work. For the political opposition line to work, I think we would need a strong Conservative leader. Instead we have John Boehner. I don't think the risk of turning reliably Red States into swing (or worse: Blue) States is worth the relatively minor gains we would see from Diaspora.
I find myself at least in partial agreement with both "Let it Burn" (surrender and retreat varieties) and with the Mass Conservative Migration retreat groups. You might call these "strategic retreats." They are falling back to stronger positions to reorganize and strengthen our "army."
Fill the comments with your thoughts. I think this is of vital importance to decide before local elections next year.
Monday, November 12, 2012
The "Liberty" Party
No, those aren't scare quotes, they're to denote that the word "Liberty" should be featured in Republican talking points.
People more in tune with such things than me have been digesting the election return numbers, but I think a couple of things are clear. First, too many people that Republicans thought would be voting didn't. Second, the margin of loss, while painful, was actually less than in 2008- that indicates we made up ground. Third, the Republican Message is scary to people who live on Government Cheese.
For an example of that, go check out this post from Ace. This isn't the only story I've heard of this kind. When one party is offering free stuff, and the other is offering responsibility, people who are dependent upon (or believe they are dependent upon) that free stuff will vote for the free stuff.
While it is actually true that Romney's plan would be better for them, they never heard that; or if they did, they didn't believe it. What they heard was that Romney wanted to end their entitlements to "pay for" tax cuts "for the rich."
So it's time to change the messaging. I noted in this space last week that part of what we need to do is infiltrate popular culture. Movies, TV, and music should all be things on which we focus. But our politicians need to fine tune the message, too.
With respect to Mark Davis, I suggest we become the "Liberty" Party. We're not for tax cuts, we're for "Economic Liberty." We're not for school choice we're for "Education Liberty." We're not against unions, we're for "Labor Liberty."
Liberty should be the national message, and it can be adapted to anything- including social issues.
Homosexual Marriage: "I'm neither for nor against same-sex marriage. However, I believe in Moral Liberty and vehemently oppose anything that would restrict churches, organizations, or even employers from having their own rules regarding who they employee or what benefits they provide based on such issues. I believe that, where it becomes a public policy issue, Liberty is better protected by the States exercising their authority than by the Federal Government making one-size-fits-all laws."
Abortion: "As a matter of official national policy, I do not have a specific stance regarding abortion. I do believe that the States should have their just Liberty, under the 10th Amendment, to make whatever laws their People see fit regarding the availability of abortions. Roe v Wade is not bad because it made abortions more easily available, but because it simultaneously usurped the role of the Congress as the Legislative branch, and violated the 10th Amendment Rights of the States."
It is important to remember that these are national stances. At the State and Local levels, you have much more room to fit yourself to your direct constituents. That also means that Republicans in Texas and Republicans in Massachusetts might take different State stances on same-sex marriage or abortion, but would take a single, unified stance at the national level.
There are probably others who are even better at this phrasing than I am, but I believe this is the message we need to be broadcasting: Liberty.
People more in tune with such things than me have been digesting the election return numbers, but I think a couple of things are clear. First, too many people that Republicans thought would be voting didn't. Second, the margin of loss, while painful, was actually less than in 2008- that indicates we made up ground. Third, the Republican Message is scary to people who live on Government Cheese.
For an example of that, go check out this post from Ace. This isn't the only story I've heard of this kind. When one party is offering free stuff, and the other is offering responsibility, people who are dependent upon (or believe they are dependent upon) that free stuff will vote for the free stuff.
While it is actually true that Romney's plan would be better for them, they never heard that; or if they did, they didn't believe it. What they heard was that Romney wanted to end their entitlements to "pay for" tax cuts "for the rich."
So it's time to change the messaging. I noted in this space last week that part of what we need to do is infiltrate popular culture. Movies, TV, and music should all be things on which we focus. But our politicians need to fine tune the message, too.
With respect to Mark Davis, I suggest we become the "Liberty" Party. We're not for tax cuts, we're for "Economic Liberty." We're not for school choice we're for "Education Liberty." We're not against unions, we're for "Labor Liberty."
Liberty should be the national message, and it can be adapted to anything- including social issues.
Homosexual Marriage: "I'm neither for nor against same-sex marriage. However, I believe in Moral Liberty and vehemently oppose anything that would restrict churches, organizations, or even employers from having their own rules regarding who they employee or what benefits they provide based on such issues. I believe that, where it becomes a public policy issue, Liberty is better protected by the States exercising their authority than by the Federal Government making one-size-fits-all laws."
Abortion: "As a matter of official national policy, I do not have a specific stance regarding abortion. I do believe that the States should have their just Liberty, under the 10th Amendment, to make whatever laws their People see fit regarding the availability of abortions. Roe v Wade is not bad because it made abortions more easily available, but because it simultaneously usurped the role of the Congress as the Legislative branch, and violated the 10th Amendment Rights of the States."
It is important to remember that these are national stances. At the State and Local levels, you have much more room to fit yourself to your direct constituents. That also means that Republicans in Texas and Republicans in Massachusetts might take different State stances on same-sex marriage or abortion, but would take a single, unified stance at the national level.
There are probably others who are even better at this phrasing than I am, but I believe this is the message we need to be broadcasting: Liberty.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)