Wednesday, July 18, 2012

The President Has a Lot on His Plate

Which of course why he's too busy to meet with his economic advisory council, but not too busy to play 100+ rounds of golf.

By now, you probably know that the President's jobs council hasn't "officially" met in over six months.  This despite a "laser-like focus on jobs."  So, when asked about it in his daily press briefing today, Jay Carney had this to say:

"there's no specific reason except that the president's obviously got a lot on his plate."

Yes, he obviously has a lot on his plate.  He has golf to play and fund-raisers to attend.  Obviously what is not on his plate, however, are the actual job duties of the President.

Tell you what, Mr. Obama, if you're so busy you can't actually do your job, how about we let someone who will actually be President be President?

Midden Meet Windmill

Someone is killing Israelis.  Israel believes that the "someone" is Iran.

Not.  Good.

With All Due Respect, That's the Point

So, looking for some content, I found this article about this study by a Liberal Think-Tank about how "restrictive" Voter ID laws will "disenfranchise millions of eligible voters."  The core complaint seems to come down to two things: first, that having the documentation to get legal voter ID is expensive, and, second, that it is inconvenient.

I have the "expensive" claim first because it is so laughable.  The study points out that a copy of a birth certificate can cost up to $25, and a marriage license (for married persons whose names don't match their birth certificates) can cost up to $20.  So, worst case scenario, it can cost $45.00 for a "free" ID.  Here's the problem:  first, you should have a copy of your birth certificate anyway.  The reason you can get copies from your courthouse are because you might lose it, not because you shouldn't have it.  You need it for all kinds of things, and the government reasonably expects that you'll just keep a copy.  The same is true of your marriage license.  There are a reason these documents exist in the first place, and the government expects you to keep a copy.  So, I'm sorry if you didn't, but even for "those below the poverty level," $45 dollars is not really that hard to come up with.  It may take some planning, but it can be done.

Now, the "inconvenient" claim.  The authors of the study don't call it merely inconvenient, and would probably be incensed at the fact I'm characterizing it that way, but it's the truth.  Their metric is people without cars who live more than 10 miles (straight line) to the nearest office issuing the required photo ID.  Now this sounds like a good metric.  Right off the bat, one thinks, "Oh, that would be a huge barrier!"  But then one should think, "Registration drives and voter busing."  There are numerous groups all across the nation which go to people's homes to help them register to vote, and who bus voters to polling stations on election day.  Are you telling me these groups aren't going to help people get to the Voter ID office?  Seriously?

Now, here is the thing.  Voting is not, in fact, a Right.  Not in the way that Free Speech is Right.  Voting is a privilege.  You can lose the privilege by committing (and being convicted of) a felony.  You can lose the privilege by choosing not to register to vote.  You can lose the privilege by being in the military (or otherwise overseas) and your state not issuing ballots in time for absentee ballots to be submitted.  I don't hear these groups complaining about that.

Here is another thing: Voting is Important.  It is the way in which Citizens influence their government most directly.  It is the way we have a voice in the direction of the country.  If you can't be inconvenienced enough to find forty-five dollars and a ride into town, I'm convinced you're not taking the responsibilities involved with voting seriously enough that I want you to vote.

In fact, there are two points to voter ID laws.  The first and most obvious is to make it harder to vote illegally.  Requiring a Government Issued photo ID makes it harder to vote as someone else, or to vote when you're not here legally.  The second, though, is as a "minimum barrier to entry."  That is, making someone get a valid voter ID means they have to exert at least a minimum amount of effort to 'prove' that they are actually interested in voting.

The Growing Police State: FDA Spying Edition

I've known about this since Monday, but the only link I had was to the NYT (here).  There's nothing I can point to that's wrong with the article- from what I've read it seems to be fairly straight news reporting.  But it is a convoluted issue, and exactly "why" it was a big deal was hard to pin down.  I knew in my gut that it was bad, but the reporting didn't make clear exactly why I was so irked, though irked I was.

Today, via the almighty Vic at the AoSHQ, I have this better link to a FoxNews article.  It's a little easier to digest, and made it much easier to pin down why this is such a bad thing.

For those who don't know, the FDA has to approve everything from new prescription drugs, to generic formulations of drugs no longer protected, to new medical devices and changes to old medical devices.  This process has been highly politicized for as long as I can remember, with the "Big Pharma" companies routinely getting drugs approved via a "fast track" process; drugs which would later either be recalled or have their approval modified.  On the other side of things were the little pharmaceutical companies who would often have drugs languish in red-tape limbo for years, and Durable Medical Equipment designers.

At least six scientists working for the FDA decided there institutional, and probably legal, problems with this arrangement, and began working on getting it fixed.  They communicated with congress and with personal attorneys, as (it seems, though I'm not clear on this) with each other.

The FDA retaliated by installing monitoring software on their work laptops- software which captured confidential communications with members of Congress as well as with their attorneys.

Now, the criminal issue here is big, but the implications are actually wider than that.  Hit the NYT and FoxNews for the criminal angle. 

The major problem with this is the brazen, even cavalier manner in which the FDA acted.  Their actions speak of a culture that brooks no dissent- which should be antithetical to science generally, and especially to medical science.  Spying on employees who disagree with you is bad enough, but to then base retaliation (which is illegal anyway) on the confidential communications thereby attained is even worse.  It cannot have anything but a chilling affect on dissent, and dissent is necessary for science to work properly.  Contrary to Al Gore's beliefs, science is not now, and has never been, about about "consensus."

To so oppose dissent, even if it dissent about policy, means the FDA is putting politics above safety and people's health.  If policy is wrong about something- and sometimes even decently crafted and well meaning policies get something wrong- then it needs to be challenged and changed.  To oppose such means the FDA is more concerned with the status quotient than they are with doing what they are mandated to do: make sure drugs and medical equipment are safe for your use.

Tuesday, July 17, 2012

In Which Sally Kohn Completely Whiffs

On FoxNews.com today, Sally Kohn has a piece in which she espouses support for Barack Obama's "You didn't do that," comment.  It deserves some deconstruction:

First, this pair of statements:
"But there were things that helped my grandfather’s business that he didn’t have to pay for."
and
"...my grandfather paid almost 50% of his income in taxes to help make sure that good public schools and safe streets and the things we all need to succeed in America would be available for the next generation."

Ms. Kohn, don't you understand that the second refutes the first?  He did have to pay for those things- through his taxes.  He didn't "owe" anyone anything for their use, because he'd already paid for it.  No more do I "owe" Dell anything for the computer I'm using to write this: the computer has already been paid for.  You only "owe" someone for something when they've provided you a good or service for which you have not compensated them.  I couldn't work without this computer, or a mouse, or internet service.  I pay for all of them and therefore "owe" nothing for them.

Next:
"Today, hedge fund managers and big business CEOs pay lower tax rates than middle class families."

This is a fallacy you hear repeated quite often, and it needs to be refuted every time.  Big Business CEOs usually pay greater than 50% of their salary when local, state, and federal taxes are considered.  Just like your grandfather, Ms. Kohn.  You refer to the fact that many of the uber-rich subsist without a salary income, and live only on the interest from previous investments: thus, they pay a lower "capital gains" tax rate.  However, you miss two things: one, that money was taxed before it was invested and two, there is no guarantee that such investments will make money in any given year.  Yes, some investments are highly secure, but none that provide enough interest to be worth discussing are guaranteed.  Further, there is the fact that you would further harm businesses by increasing the capital gains rate.  People invest in businesses, especially new businesses, to earn a profit.  If the government makes that more difficult, fewer people will be able to invest, and those who still can will be less willing to do so.

Finally (and then go read the whole thing to point, and laugh, and mock)
"The president was clear:  We succeed because of our individual initiative but also because of the public investments that help springboard that success."

This is utter Marxist bovine defecation.  If the government was so instrumental in success, does it not then also get some of the blame for the (approximated 90%) of new business failures?  Of course not, and this goes back to the first point.  My taxes paid for those things.  There is no such thing as a "public investment."  First off, investments see returns, and nothing paid for by the government ever sees a positive return.  Secondly, "the public" is not an entity that can do anything.  To try, via slight of hand, to suggest it can is pure Marxist Collectivism.  The truth is that the Government does organize some things, and pays for them with your and my tax dollars.  Or, with funny money printed by the US Treasury- which is considerably worse.

In fact, when you begin to add in government bureaucracy, regulations, business taxes, and so forth, any business which succeeds does so in spite of government, not because of it.

Oh, and just to be clear- the Government didn't always build roads or schools.  Certainly major thoroughfare roads (like US Highways and the Interstate Highway System), and government run schools are actually fairly recent inventions in human history.  Many roads were built with private funds, and most schools were run by private (mostly Religious) institutions.  Did Ben Franklin owe his success to Government?  Certainly not.  If the Government weren't building the roads, someone would be.  And I'd have to pay for their use just like I do for those "provided" by the Government.

The Growing Police State: Credit Ratings Edition

Oh.  This will end well.  It appears the Federal Government is now going to be "overseeing" the Credit Reporting agencies.  Those would be the agencies which assess how risky it is to loan various entities, from private citizens, to corporations, to governments, money.  Yes, those people who downgraded, and then (under vast political pressure) re-upgraded US Debt.

Does the term "conflict of interest" have know meaning to these people?  How about "Tyranny?"

The Orwellian Named "Consumer Financial Protection Bureau" said, Monday, that it would begin supervising the top 30 firms that make up approximately 94% of the Credit Rating industry.  Of course, this is to make things more "fair" to "consumers."

Nevermind that credit rating agencies already have every incentive- just from the market place- to get the right answers regarding creditworthiness.  If they err too often on the side of lending money, no one will trust them and they'll all go back to doing their own underwriting.  That, or new agencies which get it right more often will arise.  If the err too often on the side of not lending money, the same thing will happen.  Banks and other lenders use the Credit Reporting agencies out of convenience, not necessity.

No, the only reason for this move is to prevent further embarrassment to national governments, or government agencies, from having their credit ratings downgraded.  This is a bald-faced threat.  This is a statement, "Remember who controls you."  Or, perhaps, "I'm altering the deal.  Pray I do not alter it futher."

Marxism, Pure and Simple

In a post yesterday, I asked whether the President is a demagogue or just stupid.  Frankly, I think the answer is "yes," but in regards to the specific comments he made regarding business success, I think there is a more appropriate answer.  He's a full out, Karl Marx Communist.  The line about business owners not doing it themselves, followed by the non sequitur about "everyone having their own fire response" or whatever, is pure Communist Manifesto.

Let me explain.  His comment was not simply saying that businesses rely on roads and infrastructure, which they do, but that because they rely on these things they owe their success to "The People."  Well, they can't pay back "The People," now can they?  Among other things, there would be no reasonable way to apportion any repayment (assuming such was needed- which it isn't).  Instead, these businesses must "repay" the Government.

That is, any successful business should be owned by the Government.  Which economic and political system espouses that, again?  Oh.  That's right.  Communism.

And, just like the Communist he is at heart, Mr. Obama then went with the public services fallacy.  This is the idea that, since things have to be organized, all things must be centrally organized.  That is: because cities maintain fire departments, instead of there being private companies that provide the service, and everyone needs that protection, everyone should be answerable to government because of that.  Apparently the Communists have never head of Volunteer Fire Departments.

This is important.  It is important to understand where the President is getting his ideas.  Whether or not he believes himself to be a Communist, that's where his heart and head are.  Whether or not he thinks of himself that way, his inclinations are to Nationalize everything.

In November you have a choice: a slightly out-of-touch, but pro-American and pro-Capitalism candidate, or a Crypto-Marxist.