So, for weeks, if not months, we've heard nothing from Democrats on the "Fiscal Cliff" except for the need to "raise revenue" by which they mean tax rates. This is such a thoroughly silly idea, that it doesn't even bear the most basic of scrutiny. For one thing, we don't have a "revenue" problem, we have a spending problem. For another, raising tax rates does not actually increase government revenue. If anything, it has a depressive effect by also slowing growth.
Now, however, we finally have some movement on the Democrat side. They've shifted positions! Wait, no, that was the goal-posts they just moved. See, now, it's not enough that we merely raise tax rates on actual job and wealth creators. No, now we also have to further extend Unemployment Benefits past 99 weeks. As though nearly 2 years of unemployment was not absurd enough, now it needs to be longer.
Let's assume that Democrats were negotiating, in the beginning, in good faith. Let's say they really wanted to reduce the deficits and (eventually) start paying down the debt. Let's further grant that they really believe that increasing tax rates will increase revenues this time, despite its utter failure every time it's been tried in the 40+ years. Even assuming those things (which aren't true, but go with me here), does it make sense then to further increase spending?
Even if we did have a revenue problem, and not a spending problem, in what world does it make sense to increase spending further when our deficits are already about 10% of GDP, we're already spending nearly 150% of tax receipts, and our debt is over 100% of GDP?
The short answer: none. It doesn't make sense. Increasing spending is the absolute wrong thing to do to close the deficits, even if you grant that increasing tax rates would increase revenue.
If that is the case; it if it is true that increasing spending is absolutely and obviously counter-productive, then it follows that the Democrats were never negotiating in good faith. They want the Fiscal Cliff. They want higher taxes on everyone. They simply assume that the spending will continue. Since we haven't had a budget in 4 years, but we've been spending anyway, I don't see how they're wrong, either.
Republicans must not budge on this. Let's go over the fiscal cliff together. And then, when it's time for another "continuing resolution" to keep spending money we don't have? Don't do that either. When it's time to increase the debt ceiling again? Don't do that, either.
The American People voted for the Fiscal Cliff. They also voted for deadlock, since they didn't see fit to give the Democrats the house back, or even a filibuster proof majority in the Senate. Give them what they asked for.
Let it burn.
Monday, December 10, 2012
GOP Communication Classes?
On the CBS morning show "This Morning" Dick Armey suggested that much of the Republican plight in the November election stemmed from candidates who "said some dumb things." He believes the Republican Party needs to educate candidates on how to avoid saying such dumb things. With due respect to former Leader Armey, this is hogwash. No one should need to be "educated" so that they don't say that the body has rape-sensing hormones that prevent pregnancy, or that rape is "a blessing." In fact, no one did say the latter, and the former was at least based on a scientific hypothesis. The hypothesis has been soundly debunked, but it was an actually proffered hypothesis once.
No, the Republican Party needs to figure out that the Tea Party isn't going anywhere, and join forces. If the Republican party would partner with local tea party groups to help vet candidates, and put forward candidates who are both acceptable to grass-roots conservatives and unlikely to say "dumb things" in the first place, then we'd be in a better position. The problem with that is that the Tea Party represents opposition to much of what is wrong with the Republican Party, and the Republican Party doesn't like to admit that it has things wrong with it.
Until the local Tea Parties are accepted as legitimate partners with the Republicans, the two will work to cross purposes and Democrats will continue to be elected. In those instances when Republicans have embraced the Tea Party, they have experience success. Take a look at the Texas Congressional Delegation, for instance. Scott Brown was elected on Tea Party sentiment. He was not re-elected because he tried to out-Democrat the Democrat.
Communication is, indeed, an issue. It probably did cost us a couple of otherwise safe seats. But rather than focus on the window-dressing, the Republican Party needs to partner with grass-roots groups to help select men and women who are already able purveyors of the Conservative Message.
No, the Republican Party needs to figure out that the Tea Party isn't going anywhere, and join forces. If the Republican party would partner with local tea party groups to help vet candidates, and put forward candidates who are both acceptable to grass-roots conservatives and unlikely to say "dumb things" in the first place, then we'd be in a better position. The problem with that is that the Tea Party represents opposition to much of what is wrong with the Republican Party, and the Republican Party doesn't like to admit that it has things wrong with it.
Until the local Tea Parties are accepted as legitimate partners with the Republicans, the two will work to cross purposes and Democrats will continue to be elected. In those instances when Republicans have embraced the Tea Party, they have experience success. Take a look at the Texas Congressional Delegation, for instance. Scott Brown was elected on Tea Party sentiment. He was not re-elected because he tried to out-Democrat the Democrat.
Communication is, indeed, an issue. It probably did cost us a couple of otherwise safe seats. But rather than focus on the window-dressing, the Republican Party needs to partner with grass-roots groups to help select men and women who are already able purveyors of the Conservative Message.
Friday, December 7, 2012
Michael Moore: "Go Union!" History: "That's New."
Michael Moore is on twitter spewing against Michigan's Right To Work law, just passed by their legislature. According to him it's some kind of travesty. Never mind that every right to work state in the nation is doing better, economically, than Michigan right now.
So, on twitter, he claimed that anyone working on his next movie would have to be part of the union. Well, that's his choice, really, but it would be a departure. See, as recently as 2009 (the last time he made a movie), Michael Moore was avoiding using union labor wherever he could.
It's always so strange to me that these limousine liberals are all pro-union- right up until they see what union labor costs.
So, on twitter, he claimed that anyone working on his next movie would have to be part of the union. Well, that's his choice, really, but it would be a departure. See, as recently as 2009 (the last time he made a movie), Michael Moore was avoiding using union labor wherever he could.
It's always so strange to me that these limousine liberals are all pro-union- right up until they see what union labor costs.
Yet More BLS BS
So the November Unemployment numbers came out today. The BLS claims 146K jobs created (just under what's needed to keep up with population growth) and yet somehow unemployment dropped from 7.9% to 7.7%. Quietly released also were downward revisions in the numbers for both September and October.
Now, beyond the obvious question of how the UE Rate could go down when we're not even employing people at the replacement rate is the question of why the BLS would produce such obviously faulty numbers. The answer to the first is easy enough. Part of it is legitimate; yet more people are no longer counted as "unemployed" even though they are, in fact, "unemployed." Part of it is not. This number is fairly obviously false, and will be quietly revised downward next month or the month after.
So the question that remains is "why?" Why produce these numbers that are, to anyone paying attention, obviously incorrect if not outright fraudulent?
On this, I have a theory. It's not exactly a secret that the Bureau of Labor Statistics works for the President. Prior to the election, they were padding the numbers (thus the quiet downward revisions for September and October's numbers) to help Obama get re-elected. The Media helped with this, too, by absolutely refusing to analyze the unemployment numbers at all. But what incentive does the Administration have to lie now?
My answer: the Fiscal Cliff negotiations. Right now, just over half the country says they would blame Republicans more than Democrats if we re-entered a recession due to the fiscal cliff. It is my belief that people would blame Democrats more if they knew how bad the economy really was. If people saw 8%+ unemployment rates, they'd realize that we aren't in some "weak recovery" but still in a recession which has been extended by the disastrous policies of this President. If people understood that, they would realize that the people who actually want to help them and help grow the economy are the Republicans.
Any support for increased taxation would evaporate. The calls for "the rich" to pay "their fair share," would be nonexistent. People would begin to understand that we do not have a "revenue" problem. And then the Republicans would have much more power in Congress. They would have more power because even the Democrat controlled Senate would start feeling the pressure to reduce spending, rather than attempt to raise taxes. The Democrats would start feeling constituent pressure to reduce regulation, and start loosening the Government's strangle-hold on the economy.
So we get the same "sunny days are here again" news we got prior to the election. Once we've gone over the fiscal cliff, as Democrats want, we might start seeing real numbers again. See, then, it will be because those Evil Republicans were just too hyper-partisan and wouldn't just give Obama everything he wanted. Instead, those Evil, Intractable Republicans wanted Obama actually to negotiate! In good faith! How dare they!?
Now, beyond the obvious question of how the UE Rate could go down when we're not even employing people at the replacement rate is the question of why the BLS would produce such obviously faulty numbers. The answer to the first is easy enough. Part of it is legitimate; yet more people are no longer counted as "unemployed" even though they are, in fact, "unemployed." Part of it is not. This number is fairly obviously false, and will be quietly revised downward next month or the month after.
So the question that remains is "why?" Why produce these numbers that are, to anyone paying attention, obviously incorrect if not outright fraudulent?
On this, I have a theory. It's not exactly a secret that the Bureau of Labor Statistics works for the President. Prior to the election, they were padding the numbers (thus the quiet downward revisions for September and October's numbers) to help Obama get re-elected. The Media helped with this, too, by absolutely refusing to analyze the unemployment numbers at all. But what incentive does the Administration have to lie now?
My answer: the Fiscal Cliff negotiations. Right now, just over half the country says they would blame Republicans more than Democrats if we re-entered a recession due to the fiscal cliff. It is my belief that people would blame Democrats more if they knew how bad the economy really was. If people saw 8%+ unemployment rates, they'd realize that we aren't in some "weak recovery" but still in a recession which has been extended by the disastrous policies of this President. If people understood that, they would realize that the people who actually want to help them and help grow the economy are the Republicans.
Any support for increased taxation would evaporate. The calls for "the rich" to pay "their fair share," would be nonexistent. People would begin to understand that we do not have a "revenue" problem. And then the Republicans would have much more power in Congress. They would have more power because even the Democrat controlled Senate would start feeling the pressure to reduce spending, rather than attempt to raise taxes. The Democrats would start feeling constituent pressure to reduce regulation, and start loosening the Government's strangle-hold on the economy.
So we get the same "sunny days are here again" news we got prior to the election. Once we've gone over the fiscal cliff, as Democrats want, we might start seeing real numbers again. See, then, it will be because those Evil Republicans were just too hyper-partisan and wouldn't just give Obama everything he wanted. Instead, those Evil, Intractable Republicans wanted Obama actually to negotiate! In good faith! How dare they!?
#CultureWar: Madison Rising
Welcome to the first in a new post category for Dedicated Tenther. #CultureWar will focus on Conservatives in the trenches in the Culture War. Mostly this will focus on music, because that's where we're best represented.
If you have tips about any #CultureWar soldiers (that would be: entertainers who are conservative, and not shy about it) please send them my way.
****
Madison Rising is a Conservative Rock (yes, apparently this is a genre) band. You've probably heard or seen their version of the Star Spangled Banner. That's only the tip of their rock and roll iceberg. You can buy their music (please do) via the iTunes store or CD Baby, or you can just donate to the band via Pay-Pal (but why, when they're music is so good?).
I've listened to some of their music, and I have to say it's good. This is not a case of a band receiving praise because they're trying to fill a niche I see needs to be filled, but because they fill it well. Just as conservatives can listen to liberal weenies like (insert band here) and just enjoy the music, anyone can just listen to Madison Rising for some good hard rock and roll.
Their Star Spangled Banner is below the fold. Go check 'em out and send them some of your coin.
If you have tips about any #CultureWar soldiers (that would be: entertainers who are conservative, and not shy about it) please send them my way.
****
Madison Rising is a Conservative Rock (yes, apparently this is a genre) band. You've probably heard or seen their version of the Star Spangled Banner. That's only the tip of their rock and roll iceberg. You can buy their music (please do) via the iTunes store or CD Baby, or you can just donate to the band via Pay-Pal (but why, when they're music is so good?).
I've listened to some of their music, and I have to say it's good. This is not a case of a band receiving praise because they're trying to fill a niche I see needs to be filled, but because they fill it well. Just as conservatives can listen to liberal weenies like (insert band here) and just enjoy the music, anyone can just listen to Madison Rising for some good hard rock and roll.
Their Star Spangled Banner is below the fold. Go check 'em out and send them some of your coin.
Thursday, December 6, 2012
The Politics of Conflict
Going back to 1972, at least, a good rule of thumb is that Republicans will lose low turnout elections. High turnout elections have tended towards Republicans, but the reason for the high turnout matters. For instance, Clinton's election in 1992 was a very high turnout, but the semi-spoiler of Ross Perot gave it to the Democrat. Barack Obama's election in 2008 was very high turnout, as people turned out to vote for the First Black President. However, both the 96 and 2012 elections had many fewer votes, relative to the prior cycle.
So it seems that the Republicans' best chance to win elections is to encourage high turnout. High turnout gives Republicans a much better chance of winning than low turnout. So the question becomes, "how do we encourage high turn out?"
Here, I have a suggestion. I do not remember the 1980 and 1984 elections at all. I do recall the 1988 election some (c'mon, I was 8), and I remember 92 and on pretty well. Basing this guess on what I've heard about the Reagan elections, I feel fairly safe in making the suggestion. Conflict wins elections for Republicans.
Reagan did not just run against Carter in 1980, he ran against the idea of Carter as well. That is, he clearly defined two teams, and then asked American voters to join one. People voted in droves, and mostly chose Reagan's team. When Bush 41 ran in 1988, he drew similar team lines. "Read my lips, no new taxes." Contrariwise, Bush 41 lost to Clinton in 92 because he'd reneged on that "no new taxes" pledge, and people could see no difference between the two. The guy who tried to draw clear team lines was Ross Perot, who didn't have the needed infrastructure to win. Bush 44 barely won over Al Gore. The reason that election was so close was, once again, the lines between the two "teams" were blurred.
Of note here is that I'm using the term "team" on purpose. This isn't about parties. One thing Ross Perot's runs in 92 and 96 prove is that there are certain partisans who will always vote for their party. Those aren't the ones who are choosing a team in each election. The teams are for those who are less partisan. Maybe they normally vote R or D, but they can be persuaded. Maybe they don't normally vote at all.
So how do we draw those team lines? We use conflict. Reagan was good at doing this affably, but the conflict needs to exist. Let's take a couple of looks at popular culture to make the point.
American wrestling, currently existing as the WWE, used to be a very minor niche of entertainment, and just didn't have a following. That all changed decades ago, when someone- I'm not sure any but those who were following then even remembers who- decided to make the show more exciting. How was that done? He took the persona of the bad guy. Now, audiences had someone to root against (him) and, by extension, someone to root for. To this day, the WWE uses this formula, and experiences great commercial success. Professional boxing is trying to do the same thing through building up and promoting rivalries.
American Idol burst onto the scene 11 years ago. From the beginning it was wildly popular. However, the 2011 season was weak, and the 2012 season was weaker. The show is flailing trying to maintain its power. What changed? Simon Cowell left. Simon Cowell, the acerbic Brit and primary judge, was the primary draw for the show. Why? Because he created conflict. While everyone else was heaping praise on contestants, Simon would make up some off-the-wall simile to say "that sucked." It drove conflict on the judging panel, and it drove conflict with the contestants. You could root for or against Simon, and therefore for or against specific contestants or the other judges. With him gone, there is no conflict. Randy has tried to fill his shoes by being a little more honest with the contestants, but he doesn't drive conflict. He's too conciliatory when he's telling someone they suck. So Idol is in decline.
It is this last part that I think is important. No one who was paying attention could seriously believe that Mitt Romney and the SCOAMT had any positions really in common. There was disagreement. However, Mitt Romney seemed to run from conflict. Mere disagreement will not suffice; a clear conflict, a rivalry is necessary. It gets people excited and encourages them to pick a side. Instead, people didn't see that there were sides to pick, and so people stayed home.
If Republicans want to win the White House in 2016 (assuming The Great Collapse has not already occurred), they must embrace conflict. When the Democrat says, "We need to raise revenue," the Republican needs to respond "No, we don't." Direct contradiction is the most basic form of conflict. It gets people's attention. Imagine if, during the debates, SCOAMT had said, "...and so I'm proposing to raise revenue by blah, blah..." and Romney had immediately rejoined, "Raise revenue? Don't you mean raise taxes? Please, Mr. President, be honest with the American people. And while we're being honest; we don't have a problem with revenue, we have a problem with spending."
That's a clear line. That creates Team Raise Taxes and Team Cut Spending. On item after item Romney could have chosen to engage in conflict, and therefore give the American People some one to root for and someone to root against. Had he done so, maybe we'd be talking about President Elect Romney today.
So it seems that the Republicans' best chance to win elections is to encourage high turnout. High turnout gives Republicans a much better chance of winning than low turnout. So the question becomes, "how do we encourage high turn out?"
Here, I have a suggestion. I do not remember the 1980 and 1984 elections at all. I do recall the 1988 election some (c'mon, I was 8), and I remember 92 and on pretty well. Basing this guess on what I've heard about the Reagan elections, I feel fairly safe in making the suggestion. Conflict wins elections for Republicans.
Reagan did not just run against Carter in 1980, he ran against the idea of Carter as well. That is, he clearly defined two teams, and then asked American voters to join one. People voted in droves, and mostly chose Reagan's team. When Bush 41 ran in 1988, he drew similar team lines. "Read my lips, no new taxes." Contrariwise, Bush 41 lost to Clinton in 92 because he'd reneged on that "no new taxes" pledge, and people could see no difference between the two. The guy who tried to draw clear team lines was Ross Perot, who didn't have the needed infrastructure to win. Bush 44 barely won over Al Gore. The reason that election was so close was, once again, the lines between the two "teams" were blurred.
Of note here is that I'm using the term "team" on purpose. This isn't about parties. One thing Ross Perot's runs in 92 and 96 prove is that there are certain partisans who will always vote for their party. Those aren't the ones who are choosing a team in each election. The teams are for those who are less partisan. Maybe they normally vote R or D, but they can be persuaded. Maybe they don't normally vote at all.
So how do we draw those team lines? We use conflict. Reagan was good at doing this affably, but the conflict needs to exist. Let's take a couple of looks at popular culture to make the point.
American wrestling, currently existing as the WWE, used to be a very minor niche of entertainment, and just didn't have a following. That all changed decades ago, when someone- I'm not sure any but those who were following then even remembers who- decided to make the show more exciting. How was that done? He took the persona of the bad guy. Now, audiences had someone to root against (him) and, by extension, someone to root for. To this day, the WWE uses this formula, and experiences great commercial success. Professional boxing is trying to do the same thing through building up and promoting rivalries.
American Idol burst onto the scene 11 years ago. From the beginning it was wildly popular. However, the 2011 season was weak, and the 2012 season was weaker. The show is flailing trying to maintain its power. What changed? Simon Cowell left. Simon Cowell, the acerbic Brit and primary judge, was the primary draw for the show. Why? Because he created conflict. While everyone else was heaping praise on contestants, Simon would make up some off-the-wall simile to say "that sucked." It drove conflict on the judging panel, and it drove conflict with the contestants. You could root for or against Simon, and therefore for or against specific contestants or the other judges. With him gone, there is no conflict. Randy has tried to fill his shoes by being a little more honest with the contestants, but he doesn't drive conflict. He's too conciliatory when he's telling someone they suck. So Idol is in decline.
It is this last part that I think is important. No one who was paying attention could seriously believe that Mitt Romney and the SCOAMT had any positions really in common. There was disagreement. However, Mitt Romney seemed to run from conflict. Mere disagreement will not suffice; a clear conflict, a rivalry is necessary. It gets people excited and encourages them to pick a side. Instead, people didn't see that there were sides to pick, and so people stayed home.
If Republicans want to win the White House in 2016 (assuming The Great Collapse has not already occurred), they must embrace conflict. When the Democrat says, "We need to raise revenue," the Republican needs to respond "No, we don't." Direct contradiction is the most basic form of conflict. It gets people's attention. Imagine if, during the debates, SCOAMT had said, "...and so I'm proposing to raise revenue by blah, blah..." and Romney had immediately rejoined, "Raise revenue? Don't you mean raise taxes? Please, Mr. President, be honest with the American people. And while we're being honest; we don't have a problem with revenue, we have a problem with spending."
That's a clear line. That creates Team Raise Taxes and Team Cut Spending. On item after item Romney could have chosen to engage in conflict, and therefore give the American People some one to root for and someone to root against. Had he done so, maybe we'd be talking about President Elect Romney today.
Wednesday, December 5, 2012
We Do Not Have A Revenue Problem
As the deadline to stop the automatic tax increases and budget cuts collectively known as the "Fiscal Cliff" looms ever larger, we here a lot about "increased revenue." This is simply 1984 Newspeak for "tax rate hikes." The only question, it seems, is whether they should be called tax hikes, in which case actual marginal rates would go up, or whether it should be called "closing loopholes," and use the obfuscation of keeping marginal rates the same but removing deductions to increase taxes. Based on both the Republicans' and Democrats' talking points, you'd think that the United States Government was the orphan Oliver asking, "Please sir, I'd like some more."
This is ludicrous. The United States does not have a revenue problem, we have a spending problem.
According to usgovernmentrevenue.com, the United States Government took in 2.486 trillion dollars in 2012. According to Economy Watch, the projected US GDP for 2012 is 15.880 trillion dollars. This means that the US Government will take in around 15.6% of GDP in direct revenue. This a little on the low side, but well within statistical averages for the last several decades.
Taking in roughly 1/7th of the GDP as revenue should be more than sufficient. The problem is not revenue. The problem is spending. For 2012, the US Deficit is projected to be over 1.3 trillion dollars. That means the United States is spending more than 150% of the revenue it takes in. Total Debt is projected to be over 16 trillion dollars, or roughly 103% of GDP.
This is insane. There is no way, if we confiscated all the wealth from every person living in the United States, that we could pay our bills. This is like a family making $250,000/yr spending $380,000, and already being over one million dollars in debt. What has to be cut is spending. And the biggest drains on the treasury are entitlements, followed by military spending.
Any discussion of the budget that does not include massive cuts to entitlement and (sorry, to say) military spending is simply not serious. Any discussion of the budget which has as its premise that we need higher revenue is simply not serious. It is political posturing, and posing for the cameras. Such discussions are aimed to score political points and harm political opponents. Anyone engaging in such rhetoric should be immediately dismissed as unserious, at best, and disingenuous at worst.
Speaker Boehner, this means you.
This is ludicrous. The United States does not have a revenue problem, we have a spending problem.
According to usgovernmentrevenue.com, the United States Government took in 2.486 trillion dollars in 2012. According to Economy Watch, the projected US GDP for 2012 is 15.880 trillion dollars. This means that the US Government will take in around 15.6% of GDP in direct revenue. This a little on the low side, but well within statistical averages for the last several decades.
Taking in roughly 1/7th of the GDP as revenue should be more than sufficient. The problem is not revenue. The problem is spending. For 2012, the US Deficit is projected to be over 1.3 trillion dollars. That means the United States is spending more than 150% of the revenue it takes in. Total Debt is projected to be over 16 trillion dollars, or roughly 103% of GDP.
This is insane. There is no way, if we confiscated all the wealth from every person living in the United States, that we could pay our bills. This is like a family making $250,000/yr spending $380,000, and already being over one million dollars in debt. What has to be cut is spending. And the biggest drains on the treasury are entitlements, followed by military spending.
Any discussion of the budget that does not include massive cuts to entitlement and (sorry, to say) military spending is simply not serious. Any discussion of the budget which has as its premise that we need higher revenue is simply not serious. It is political posturing, and posing for the cameras. Such discussions are aimed to score political points and harm political opponents. Anyone engaging in such rhetoric should be immediately dismissed as unserious, at best, and disingenuous at worst.
Speaker Boehner, this means you.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)