In the first post discussing my final considerations in voting for Mitt Romney, I discussed the case against Barack Obama. In this, the second part, I will discuss the positive case for Mitt Romney.
In many ways, Mitt Romney is a blank slate, even to this day. He Governed in Massachusetts as a moderate, "reach-across-the-aisle" Republican. He lent his name to RomneyCare, the Massachusetts socialized health care plan.
So why would a Dedicated Tenther vote for Mitt Romney?
Largely it is because I am a Dedicated Tenther, and Mitt Romney's performances in the debates, as well as his stump speeches, lead me to believe he is also a Tenther, if not as dedicated as I am to that cause.
When he ran in 2008, Mitt Romney was already discussing RomneyCare in terms of the 10th Amendment. He understood then that people in other states didn't like it, and was promising not to force it on the rest of the states. As a candidate this time around he has claimed, loud and often, that he would immediately waive the requirements of ObamaCare for all 50 States. He can do that on his on recognizance, with no input from Congress at all. He has then also said that he would pursue "Repeal and Replace." The "Replace" part of that makes me a little nervous, but the Repeal is absolutely necessary.
One of the solutions that his running-mate, Paul Ryan, suggested to fix Medicaid, and one that Mr. Romney seems to have accepted, is the idea of block-grants to the States for them to run their own Medicaid programs. This is not quite as good, philosophically, as doing away with it all together, but it may be the most realistic Conservative solution.
Similarly, unlike Mr. Obama, Mr. Romney has put forth plans, at least in general terms, for fixing both Medicare and Social Security. Here I want to make a point that is often overlooked. Republicans are often attacked for wanting to "end" or "privatize" Medicare and Social Security. While it is true we believe that private solutions are probably much better than Government solutions, there is another question that never gets asked: what is the Democrats' plan? They never seem to have an answer for that. At least Mr. Romney is willing to lead and put forth a plan.
In short, everything Mr. Obama is fiscally, Mr. Romney is not. The reverse is also true.
Socially, I believe that Mr. Romney and I share much of the same space. That is this: shut up about social issues. But, if you're going to make social issues into political issues, we're both coming down on the side of social conservatism. I do not believe that Mitt Romney will particularly pursue the reimplementation of Don't Ask Don't Tell. I do think, given the chance, he would continue to defend DOMA. I do think, if people made homosexuality in the military a big issue, he would side with social conservatives.
Regarding foreign policy, I do not know how Mitt Romney will pursue his course, or how he will direct our nation. I do know two things. I know he would not leave our personnel to die in an under-defended diplomatic mission just to further his own political goals. I also know that he's listening to at least some of the right people. Among those is former Ambassador John Bolton.
Ultimately, however, the question comes down to character. During the primaries, I did not trust that Mitt Romney was the kind of man I wanted to be President. He had not made that case to me. The truth his, he has never made that case for himself, but those around him have. They have told stories of his character, his patience, and his charity. They have told the stories of the things he did when he thought no one would notice. And those stories have reassured me.
Four years ago, I drug myself to the poling place to vote for John McCain. It was painful, and I didn't want to do it, but I did. In 5 days, I will walk into my poling place with a song in my heart and vote for Mitt Romney for President.
Showing posts with label Mitt Romney. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mitt Romney. Show all posts
Thursday, November 1, 2012
Wednesday, October 17, 2012
Obama is Right: Mitt Romney's Tax Rate Isn't Fair
It's way too high.
This isn't quite going to be a "burn the mathwitch!" post, but it may be a little dense. I'll try to keep it as accessible as possible.
Before we can get into the specifics of Mitt Romney's tax rate (by the way, as an absolute number, he paid more than something like 90% of taxpayers), we need to review a couple of concepts. First, what is "money?" Second, what is "income?" Third, what is "time-value?" Fourth, What is "taxation?"
Money is not real. Money, on its own, is a worthless abstraction. Whether we're talking about coin money, bullion, paper money, or ones and zeros in a computer, money doesn't mean anything on its own. Despite its ephemeral nature, money is vital to our economy.
What money "is" is an abstraction of barter. If you want to think of it in these terms, our entire economy is an abstraction of previous barter-based economies. Instead of carrying around all that bread we baked, or the eggs our hens laid, and having to trade them separately for the things we want, we can take them and sell them all at one location for money, and then use that money to buy the things we want. In either case, it's the baked bread or laid eggs which are being "traded," the money just abstracts that away.
And it is a powerful abstraction. Because of the concept of money, we can have a service-based economy where instead of selling bread or eggs, I can sell my labor. In fact, wasn't it my labor I was "selling" when I was trading bread or eggs? It wasn't the bread that sold, it was the convenience of the person to whom I traded it of not having to bake it themselves. Because I used my labor to bake the bread, or raise the hens and gather the eggs, someone else had time, instead, to weave cloth, or make nails, or whatever.
In short, money is an abstraction of the value of our time and labor to create something (whether a good or service) to sell.
Income is money you earn. It is different from "capital gains" for a couple of reasons (we'll get to "time-value of money" in a bit), but among those is this one: capital gains are interest on investments (capital), whereas "income" or "earned income" is wages paid for work. Those are both over-simplifications, but they'll do for our purposes. That is, income is as much a process as a thing.
When I bake bread and sell it, or gather eggs and sell them, the money I get in return is income.
Time-value means, literally, the value of something over time. When applied to money, it is the concept that a dollar today is worth more than that same dollar would be tomorrow. If I earn a dollar, and then immediately use it, it provides its full value. Maybe I used it to buy groceries. Maybe I put it in a mutual fund or other investment. In either case, I got its full value because I exploited its utility immediately. The same dollar, tomorrow, will be worth less. It will have the same purchasing power, but it would have given up a day's worth of interest, or a day's worth of use of whatever I'd purchased. Additionally, it required resources on my part to keep it- a wallet, or a safe, or whatever.
Now, when we're talking one day and one dollar, the time-value is so infinitesimal as to be not worth noting. When we're talking a lot of money, or a lot of time, it can be significant.
One of the effects of the time-value of money is interest. This applies both on investments (interest earned) and on credit (interest paid/owed). When I invest my money, I'm letting you use it. If you were to return it to me in a year, that same money (because I wasn't able to use it) would be worth less to me. So you pay me interest, or dividends, or whatever. You are not actually paying me more than I lent you (even though you are paying more than you borrowed), you're replacing the actual value of the money you borrowed and used.
Taxation is removal of money from the economy. It's that simple. When the government takes money away from me, they have taken something of value and they have not replaced it. Now, I may get some value from the use of that dollar- in the case of roads, or national defense, or what have you, but I may not either, if it's used for welfare or "studies" determining if a watched pot really doesn't boil. In either case the dollar has been removed from the economy, in practical terms. Any benefit I receive is purely coincidental.
So, when Mitt Romney was asked if it was "fair" that people "like him" who made millions of dollars paid less in taxes than poorer people, he said, "Yes." However, he was wrong. It wasn't fair. He's paying too much.
Let's take a look again- the interest (capital gains) he "earned" on his investments were not an increase in value, they were a replacement of value he had provided, a "making good" if you will. He had already been taxed- at the much higher "income" percentage- on the income he then used to make those investments. The difference in the 5, 10, or 20% interest he earned and the 1.025% you're earning on your money-market account is due to several factors, but among those is that his money had provided greater value to those to whom he loaned it.
When viewed properly, taxing earned interest is a double-dip taxation. It's taxing the value of money which had already been taxed.
In last night's debate, Mitt Romney mentioned doing away with capital gains taxes on middle-income earners. The reason that works is that the money has already been taxed. Actually, much of it would then never be taxed, as it comes out "pre-tax" on people's paychecks. I don't think that goes far enough, though. I simply think the capital gains tax should be eliminated at all levels.
I am not a rich man. I'm one of those "middle income earners" who, I guess, is supposed to be outraged that Mitt Romney is rich. I'm not, because I understand why he pays a (theoretically) lower tax rate than I do. And I want to be able to enjoy that when I'm rich some day, too.
This isn't quite going to be a "burn the mathwitch!" post, but it may be a little dense. I'll try to keep it as accessible as possible.
Before we can get into the specifics of Mitt Romney's tax rate (by the way, as an absolute number, he paid more than something like 90% of taxpayers), we need to review a couple of concepts. First, what is "money?" Second, what is "income?" Third, what is "time-value?" Fourth, What is "taxation?"
Money is not real. Money, on its own, is a worthless abstraction. Whether we're talking about coin money, bullion, paper money, or ones and zeros in a computer, money doesn't mean anything on its own. Despite its ephemeral nature, money is vital to our economy.
What money "is" is an abstraction of barter. If you want to think of it in these terms, our entire economy is an abstraction of previous barter-based economies. Instead of carrying around all that bread we baked, or the eggs our hens laid, and having to trade them separately for the things we want, we can take them and sell them all at one location for money, and then use that money to buy the things we want. In either case, it's the baked bread or laid eggs which are being "traded," the money just abstracts that away.
And it is a powerful abstraction. Because of the concept of money, we can have a service-based economy where instead of selling bread or eggs, I can sell my labor. In fact, wasn't it my labor I was "selling" when I was trading bread or eggs? It wasn't the bread that sold, it was the convenience of the person to whom I traded it of not having to bake it themselves. Because I used my labor to bake the bread, or raise the hens and gather the eggs, someone else had time, instead, to weave cloth, or make nails, or whatever.
In short, money is an abstraction of the value of our time and labor to create something (whether a good or service) to sell.
Income is money you earn. It is different from "capital gains" for a couple of reasons (we'll get to "time-value of money" in a bit), but among those is this one: capital gains are interest on investments (capital), whereas "income" or "earned income" is wages paid for work. Those are both over-simplifications, but they'll do for our purposes. That is, income is as much a process as a thing.
When I bake bread and sell it, or gather eggs and sell them, the money I get in return is income.
Time-value means, literally, the value of something over time. When applied to money, it is the concept that a dollar today is worth more than that same dollar would be tomorrow. If I earn a dollar, and then immediately use it, it provides its full value. Maybe I used it to buy groceries. Maybe I put it in a mutual fund or other investment. In either case, I got its full value because I exploited its utility immediately. The same dollar, tomorrow, will be worth less. It will have the same purchasing power, but it would have given up a day's worth of interest, or a day's worth of use of whatever I'd purchased. Additionally, it required resources on my part to keep it- a wallet, or a safe, or whatever.
Now, when we're talking one day and one dollar, the time-value is so infinitesimal as to be not worth noting. When we're talking a lot of money, or a lot of time, it can be significant.
One of the effects of the time-value of money is interest. This applies both on investments (interest earned) and on credit (interest paid/owed). When I invest my money, I'm letting you use it. If you were to return it to me in a year, that same money (because I wasn't able to use it) would be worth less to me. So you pay me interest, or dividends, or whatever. You are not actually paying me more than I lent you (even though you are paying more than you borrowed), you're replacing the actual value of the money you borrowed and used.
Taxation is removal of money from the economy. It's that simple. When the government takes money away from me, they have taken something of value and they have not replaced it. Now, I may get some value from the use of that dollar- in the case of roads, or national defense, or what have you, but I may not either, if it's used for welfare or "studies" determining if a watched pot really doesn't boil. In either case the dollar has been removed from the economy, in practical terms. Any benefit I receive is purely coincidental.
So, when Mitt Romney was asked if it was "fair" that people "like him" who made millions of dollars paid less in taxes than poorer people, he said, "Yes." However, he was wrong. It wasn't fair. He's paying too much.
Let's take a look again- the interest (capital gains) he "earned" on his investments were not an increase in value, they were a replacement of value he had provided, a "making good" if you will. He had already been taxed- at the much higher "income" percentage- on the income he then used to make those investments. The difference in the 5, 10, or 20% interest he earned and the 1.025% you're earning on your money-market account is due to several factors, but among those is that his money had provided greater value to those to whom he loaned it.
When viewed properly, taxing earned interest is a double-dip taxation. It's taxing the value of money which had already been taxed.
In last night's debate, Mitt Romney mentioned doing away with capital gains taxes on middle-income earners. The reason that works is that the money has already been taxed. Actually, much of it would then never be taxed, as it comes out "pre-tax" on people's paychecks. I don't think that goes far enough, though. I simply think the capital gains tax should be eliminated at all levels.
I am not a rich man. I'm one of those "middle income earners" who, I guess, is supposed to be outraged that Mitt Romney is rich. I'm not, because I understand why he pays a (theoretically) lower tax rate than I do. And I want to be able to enjoy that when I'm rich some day, too.
Squrirel of the Day: "Binders of Women"
With very few exceptions (this post being one of them) you can dismiss anyone bringing up Mitt Romney's line about "binders full of women" as a completely unserious political hack. For some reason, they think this reflects poorly on him as regards his beliefs about women (I'm really not sure how they got there) so let's go and look at what he actually said:
Do you see anything objectionable there? He saw a hole forming in his leadership team- his Cabinet would have been all male. That is actually a problem. While diversity, for its own sake, is not a huge virtue, there really are ways of thinking about things that woman brings to the table that a man does not. Having women in all trades just to have women in all trades is silly. Making sure your senior leadership staff is as diverse a mix as you can reasonably achieve makes a lot of sense.
Having spotted the problem, he then took specific steps to solve it: find women who were qualified. Note that he didn't make any statement about finding women who were "good enough." I'm certain that had there really not been any women available who were qualified for what he wanted them to do, he wouldn't have selected them, diversity or no. He set his staff about the job of finding qualified candidates who were female.
Having found "binders full" of candidates (obviously he's talking about their resumes or personnel files) he then also noted that he had to make some sacrifices. If anywhere, this is where I disagree with him. Part of being qualified is being available. If you want to be the primary bread-winner of your family, and work in any kind of high office (from a Governor's cabinet to being a C-Level employee at a large corporation), one of the sacrifices you have to make is time with your family. Men are expected to do this all the time, I don't see why women can't do the same- or make the choice not to go as high on the corporate ladder.
Whatever my thoughts on the matter, he made his decision. For all of his years as Governor, he then had the most women in senior positions of any of his contemporaries. If you're looking at it as a numbers game (too many supposed feminists do), that's a good thing.
A couple of other points here. The original question was about "wage equality," and the myth that women make less than men. It was initially addressed to Mr. Obama who brought up the Lilly Ledbetter Act. Two major problems here: first, the Lilly Ledbetter Act is stupid. It doesn't actually address wage equality, it simply gives women more ways to sue their employers if they decide later that they weren't given "equal pay for equal work," and puts the onus on the employer to disprove the accusation. Second, I wish Mr. Romney had asked the President, "So, if wage equality is so important to you, why do you pay female staff, on average, 17% less (or whatever the actual number is -DT) than your male staff?" Maybe he would have brought it up if he'd been given a chance to respond to Mr. Obama's response, but, as with so many other times in the debate, he was not.
ROMNEY: Thank you. And important topic, and one which I learned a great deal about, particularly as I was serving as governor of my state, because I had the chance to pull together a cabinet and all the applicants seemed to be men.
And I -- and I went to my staff, and I said, "How come all the people for these jobs are -- are all men." They said, "Well, these are the people that have the qualifications." And I said, "Well, gosh, can't we -- can't we find some -- some women that are also qualified?"
ROMNEY: And -- and so we -- we took a concerted effort to go out and find women who had backgrounds that could be qualified to become members of our cabinet.
I went to a number of women's groups and said, "Can you help us find folks," and they brought us whole binders full of women.
I was proud of the fact that after I staffed my Cabinet and my senior staff, that the University of New York in Albany did a survey of all 50 states, and concluded that mine had more women in senior leadership positions than any other state in America.
Now one of the reasons I was able to get so many good women to be part of that team was because of our recruiting effort. But number two, because I recognized that if you're going to have women in the workforce that sometimes you need to be more flexible. My chief of staff, for instance, had two kids that were still in school.
Do you see anything objectionable there? He saw a hole forming in his leadership team- his Cabinet would have been all male. That is actually a problem. While diversity, for its own sake, is not a huge virtue, there really are ways of thinking about things that woman brings to the table that a man does not. Having women in all trades just to have women in all trades is silly. Making sure your senior leadership staff is as diverse a mix as you can reasonably achieve makes a lot of sense.
Having spotted the problem, he then took specific steps to solve it: find women who were qualified. Note that he didn't make any statement about finding women who were "good enough." I'm certain that had there really not been any women available who were qualified for what he wanted them to do, he wouldn't have selected them, diversity or no. He set his staff about the job of finding qualified candidates who were female.
Having found "binders full" of candidates (obviously he's talking about their resumes or personnel files) he then also noted that he had to make some sacrifices. If anywhere, this is where I disagree with him. Part of being qualified is being available. If you want to be the primary bread-winner of your family, and work in any kind of high office (from a Governor's cabinet to being a C-Level employee at a large corporation), one of the sacrifices you have to make is time with your family. Men are expected to do this all the time, I don't see why women can't do the same- or make the choice not to go as high on the corporate ladder.
Whatever my thoughts on the matter, he made his decision. For all of his years as Governor, he then had the most women in senior positions of any of his contemporaries. If you're looking at it as a numbers game (too many supposed feminists do), that's a good thing.
A couple of other points here. The original question was about "wage equality," and the myth that women make less than men. It was initially addressed to Mr. Obama who brought up the Lilly Ledbetter Act. Two major problems here: first, the Lilly Ledbetter Act is stupid. It doesn't actually address wage equality, it simply gives women more ways to sue their employers if they decide later that they weren't given "equal pay for equal work," and puts the onus on the employer to disprove the accusation. Second, I wish Mr. Romney had asked the President, "So, if wage equality is so important to you, why do you pay female staff, on average, 17% less (or whatever the actual number is -DT) than your male staff?" Maybe he would have brought it up if he'd been given a chance to respond to Mr. Obama's response, but, as with so many other times in the debate, he was not.
Post Debate Reaction: No Research Edition (Town Hall)
Last night was the second Presidential debate between Mitt Romney and Barack Obama. This post represents my gut reaction without having done any actual research- just my observations and anything I happened to pick up via media osmosis (radio in the background, etc.).
For full disclosure: I did not watch the entire debate last night. Town hall style debates set my teeth on edge, and I'm not an undecided voter.
General Impressions: As I feared, I believed the first two questions were just whiny. "What can you do for me?" is not a legitimate question to ask of a Presidential candidate. Among other things, it misunderstands the nature of the President's powers, and completely misses what the relationship between Government and the People should be. I don't even remember the third question. It was probably whiny, too.
Candy Crowley was annoying, and I wished she would get off of my TV. Her personal style read, "I don't care." She quickly inserted herself as an extra debate opponent- cutting off Mitt Romney's responses, and asking Barack Obama leading questions as "follow ups." At one point, Mitt Romney attempted to address a bald-faced lie by the President, and was not allowed to do so. Added to her on-the-spot defense of Obama on Libya, Ms. Crowley was not merely annoying; she was an active detriment to the debate. I give her an F.
Barack Obama's tactic seemed to be "spin what can be spun, and just lie about the rest." Quite telling was when he was called out on oil and natural gas production. Mr. Romney pointed out that all of the growth in production was on private or state land, not on federal land. Mr. Obama took exception to that (with one of many lies he told that I know of) and denied that oil and gas production on federal land was down (it is). Mr. Romney then pointed out that permits for oil and natural gas production on federal land have been cut in half. Mr. Obama denied. Mr Romeny looked him straight in the eyes and asked, "Then how much did you cut them by?" Mr. Obama not only would not answer the question, he couldn't even meet Mr. Romney's eyes. Over all, Mr. Obama did just fine at getting out talking points, but that's all they were. I give him a C.
Mitt Romney won this debate in the first 30 seconds. The candidates came out and shook hands, then went to their chairs. Mr. Romney continued standing, smiling, and waving. Barack Obama sat down. Boom, dominance game (and if you don't think that's important, you haven't been paying attention) over. Add to that Mr. Romney's mastery of the facts and figures. Add to it that he had two debate opponents and was able to hold his own against them. Add to it that he was able to stay on message, "We can do better." Mr. Romney never seemed flustered, and never "just let" Mr. Obama get away with any of his lies. I give Mr. Romney a solid A.
That, of course, is the opinion of a partisan, but it appears that, on substance, independents agree with me as well.
I expect to see another point or two added to Mr. Romney's totals in the next week or so.
For full disclosure: I did not watch the entire debate last night. Town hall style debates set my teeth on edge, and I'm not an undecided voter.
General Impressions: As I feared, I believed the first two questions were just whiny. "What can you do for me?" is not a legitimate question to ask of a Presidential candidate. Among other things, it misunderstands the nature of the President's powers, and completely misses what the relationship between Government and the People should be. I don't even remember the third question. It was probably whiny, too.
Candy Crowley was annoying, and I wished she would get off of my TV. Her personal style read, "I don't care." She quickly inserted herself as an extra debate opponent- cutting off Mitt Romney's responses, and asking Barack Obama leading questions as "follow ups." At one point, Mitt Romney attempted to address a bald-faced lie by the President, and was not allowed to do so. Added to her on-the-spot defense of Obama on Libya, Ms. Crowley was not merely annoying; she was an active detriment to the debate. I give her an F.
Barack Obama's tactic seemed to be "spin what can be spun, and just lie about the rest." Quite telling was when he was called out on oil and natural gas production. Mr. Romney pointed out that all of the growth in production was on private or state land, not on federal land. Mr. Obama took exception to that (with one of many lies he told that I know of) and denied that oil and gas production on federal land was down (it is). Mr. Romney then pointed out that permits for oil and natural gas production on federal land have been cut in half. Mr. Obama denied. Mr Romeny looked him straight in the eyes and asked, "Then how much did you cut them by?" Mr. Obama not only would not answer the question, he couldn't even meet Mr. Romney's eyes. Over all, Mr. Obama did just fine at getting out talking points, but that's all they were. I give him a C.
Mitt Romney won this debate in the first 30 seconds. The candidates came out and shook hands, then went to their chairs. Mr. Romney continued standing, smiling, and waving. Barack Obama sat down. Boom, dominance game (and if you don't think that's important, you haven't been paying attention) over. Add to that Mr. Romney's mastery of the facts and figures. Add to it that he had two debate opponents and was able to hold his own against them. Add to it that he was able to stay on message, "We can do better." Mr. Romney never seemed flustered, and never "just let" Mr. Obama get away with any of his lies. I give Mr. Romney a solid A.
That, of course, is the opinion of a partisan, but it appears that, on substance, independents agree with me as well.
I expect to see another point or two added to Mr. Romney's totals in the next week or so.
Monday, October 15, 2012
Moral Deficit
The Barack Obama administration has just confirmed that the Deficit for Fiscal Year 2012 will be over $1,000,000,000,000.00. This from a President who had promised he would cut the deficit in half. Instead it increased beyond anyone's wildest expectations. As I reflected on this, my thoughts wandered to Felix Baumgartner's historic moment yesterday, becoming the first super-sonic human.
Mr. Baumgartner's feat was an incredible one. The first human to break the sound barrier using gravity alone, what Mr. Baumgartner did will live in history. He was more than a daredevil yesterday, he was, in many ways, a hero. Oh, not a Hero, like our brave men and women over seas, or the fire fighters who routinely risk their lives to save the lives and property of others. But a hero, someone to look up to, recognize the courage and achievement, and say, "I want to do that some day."
Yet it is that very heroic image which is part, I think, of the problem which has led to trillion dollar deficits. Men like Baumgartner are worshiped and lauded. So are men like Joe Flacco or Tony Romo or any other sports star. We look at what they do, we realize the training and dedication required to achieve what they have achieved, and we encourage our children to pursue their successes. But then there are men like Mitt Romney or the Koch brothers.
What those men did required no less training and dedication. In some ways, it required far more, along with an ability to delay gratification that is all too uncommon today. They achieved success that allows them to affect the world in more ways than simply making people feel good, or escape into a game for a few hours a week. Mitt Romney gives more to charity than most Americans pay in taxes. So do the Koch brothers, for that matter. Over and above that, their financial success has led to thousands, if not millions of jobs- allowing people not only to aspire to success themselves, but allowing more than a few to achieve it.
Mitt Romney founded Bain Capital. Today he is attacked over it because sometimes in the business world hard choices have to be made. These hard choices often lead to people losing their jobs, which is only one part of what makes them so hard. But over the long run, if those hard choices are made, made well, and reached quickly enough, those lost jobs turn into new jobs- usually months or even years later.
Today, there are many nationally known chains that would not exist if it weren't for Bain Capital. Staples, Outback Steakhouse, and Toys-R-Us have all been assisted by Bain, and they just represent the tip of the iceberg. Koch Industries employs thousands of people directly, and who can really measure their indirect impact?
But, today, men like Mitt Romney or the Koch brothers are not held up as minor heroes. We don't point to them on TV and tell our children, "Because of that man, Daddy has a job. If you work hard and study like they did, maybe one day you can be like them." Far from that, they are torn down as "evil capitalists," or "greedy," or any number of other epithets. They are assumed to be "only in it for themselves."
And that is the divide- that we can point to sports star, or a daredevil, or a celebrity and say, "Look at them, try to be like them," but we point to people who have really made real lives better through employment and say, "See that man? He's greedy, don't be like him." This divide is what lead to the Housing Crash, as people who couldn't afford to purchase homes thought they should be entitled to them anyway. It is what lead to the GM Bankruptcy, as the men and women employed by the company decided that the company's long term success was less important than their immediate situation. It is what is killing AMR today. And it is why the President's administration can do anything other than resign in shame for a fourth year in a row of a deficit over one trillion dollars.
Barack Obama once called an increase in the debt ceiling, "a failure of leadership," and high deficits "immoral." Like a broken clock, he was right those two times. Unfortunately, he seems to have forgotten those lofty ideas.
Mr. Baumgartner's feat was an incredible one. The first human to break the sound barrier using gravity alone, what Mr. Baumgartner did will live in history. He was more than a daredevil yesterday, he was, in many ways, a hero. Oh, not a Hero, like our brave men and women over seas, or the fire fighters who routinely risk their lives to save the lives and property of others. But a hero, someone to look up to, recognize the courage and achievement, and say, "I want to do that some day."
Yet it is that very heroic image which is part, I think, of the problem which has led to trillion dollar deficits. Men like Baumgartner are worshiped and lauded. So are men like Joe Flacco or Tony Romo or any other sports star. We look at what they do, we realize the training and dedication required to achieve what they have achieved, and we encourage our children to pursue their successes. But then there are men like Mitt Romney or the Koch brothers.
What those men did required no less training and dedication. In some ways, it required far more, along with an ability to delay gratification that is all too uncommon today. They achieved success that allows them to affect the world in more ways than simply making people feel good, or escape into a game for a few hours a week. Mitt Romney gives more to charity than most Americans pay in taxes. So do the Koch brothers, for that matter. Over and above that, their financial success has led to thousands, if not millions of jobs- allowing people not only to aspire to success themselves, but allowing more than a few to achieve it.
Mitt Romney founded Bain Capital. Today he is attacked over it because sometimes in the business world hard choices have to be made. These hard choices often lead to people losing their jobs, which is only one part of what makes them so hard. But over the long run, if those hard choices are made, made well, and reached quickly enough, those lost jobs turn into new jobs- usually months or even years later.
Today, there are many nationally known chains that would not exist if it weren't for Bain Capital. Staples, Outback Steakhouse, and Toys-R-Us have all been assisted by Bain, and they just represent the tip of the iceberg. Koch Industries employs thousands of people directly, and who can really measure their indirect impact?
But, today, men like Mitt Romney or the Koch brothers are not held up as minor heroes. We don't point to them on TV and tell our children, "Because of that man, Daddy has a job. If you work hard and study like they did, maybe one day you can be like them." Far from that, they are torn down as "evil capitalists," or "greedy," or any number of other epithets. They are assumed to be "only in it for themselves."
And that is the divide- that we can point to sports star, or a daredevil, or a celebrity and say, "Look at them, try to be like them," but we point to people who have really made real lives better through employment and say, "See that man? He's greedy, don't be like him." This divide is what lead to the Housing Crash, as people who couldn't afford to purchase homes thought they should be entitled to them anyway. It is what lead to the GM Bankruptcy, as the men and women employed by the company decided that the company's long term success was less important than their immediate situation. It is what is killing AMR today. And it is why the President's administration can do anything other than resign in shame for a fourth year in a row of a deficit over one trillion dollars.
Barack Obama once called an increase in the debt ceiling, "a failure of leadership," and high deficits "immoral." Like a broken clock, he was right those two times. Unfortunately, he seems to have forgotten those lofty ideas.
Tuesday, October 9, 2012
CNN Poll- 5 Point Romney Swing
CNN Wants you to see the headline number: O 51 / R 47, or a 4 point lead for Obama. What they don't want you to read down to is this nugget:
That's a pretty significant swing- between 3 - 6 points.
Here's the broader trend- RCP shows Romney trending up for the last 2 or 3 weeks, with an acceleration after the Debate last Wednesday.
Now, I like it when polls show my guy in the lead, and I don't like it when they show the other guy in the lead. That's natural and understandable. But polls are an imperfect snapshot of current mood, not some Word from Heaven. So when we look at polls we have to look at two things. Friend of the Blog Dave in Florida does the unenviable task of pulling apart the internals and showing what the polls would say if they were based in reality. That's one of the things. The other is the trends.
When one guy is moving up in the polls, and the other down, consistently for a couple of weeks, which of them has momentum? Which one is on a path to victory? Which has had "really a very bad week?"
This particular CNN poll is a splash of cold water- it is, we can't pretend it isn't. But even in that splash of cold water, it's carrying good news. The trend is still in our favor.
The survey, released Tuesday, was conducted October 5-8, entirely after last Wednesday's first presidential debate. Since non-partisan, live operator polls of likely voters in Ohio conducted prior to the debate indicated Obama with a 7-10 point advantage over the former Massachusetts governor, the new CNN survey suggests that Romney got a bounce following the debate.
That's a pretty significant swing- between 3 - 6 points.
Here's the broader trend- RCP shows Romney trending up for the last 2 or 3 weeks, with an acceleration after the Debate last Wednesday.
Now, I like it when polls show my guy in the lead, and I don't like it when they show the other guy in the lead. That's natural and understandable. But polls are an imperfect snapshot of current mood, not some Word from Heaven. So when we look at polls we have to look at two things. Friend of the Blog Dave in Florida does the unenviable task of pulling apart the internals and showing what the polls would say if they were based in reality. That's one of the things. The other is the trends.
When one guy is moving up in the polls, and the other down, consistently for a couple of weeks, which of them has momentum? Which one is on a path to victory? Which has had "really a very bad week?"
This particular CNN poll is a splash of cold water- it is, we can't pretend it isn't. But even in that splash of cold water, it's carrying good news. The trend is still in our favor.
New Poll- Romney + 10
That's actually a re-weighting the the IBD/TIPP that came out today.
According to friend of the Blog Dave_in_Florida, that's what happens in 2 of the 4 models when you re-weight the internals to reflect reasonable expectations. Even the very generous 2008 turnout model predicts a 5 point Romney win. Using the Rassmussen party Id for weighting results in an astounding Romney + 12.
Be sure to look into Dave's archives, he explains (with Math!) exactly the formula he uses to re-weight the polls.
Yes, it's probably an outlier. Yes, the race is probably closer than that. Right now, I just don't care.
Excuse me while I attend this schadenboner.
According to friend of the Blog Dave_in_Florida, that's what happens in 2 of the 4 models when you re-weight the internals to reflect reasonable expectations. Even the very generous 2008 turnout model predicts a 5 point Romney win. Using the Rassmussen party Id for weighting results in an astounding Romney + 12.
Be sure to look into Dave's archives, he explains (with Math!) exactly the formula he uses to re-weight the polls.
Yes, it's probably an outlier. Yes, the race is probably closer than that. Right now, I just don't care.
Excuse me while I attend this schadenboner.
Monday, October 8, 2012
A Failing Narrative
There's a new narrative the media is trying to float; it is that of Mitt Romney as a "Moderate." They're calling his debate performance that of a "Moderate Republican." They're marveling over his "sudden move to the center." They're even saying it about his very Reaganesque (in content- I don't know about delivery) speech at the Virginia Military Institute this morning.
If it weren't so serious, it would be funny.
As it is, I believe I see what they're trying to do, but I think they're going to regret the tactic. The plan seems to be an attempt to drive a wedge between the conservative base and Mr. Romney. One of the biggest criticism of Romney during the primaries, and I certainly believed it, was that he was a "North Eastern Squish." That is, that he was too moderate.
Here is why that fails, however. Romney's performance in the Debate was many people's first introduction. In the debate, he was not "moderate." His answers were fairly orthodox conservatism. Lower taxes. Lower spending. Less regulation. More free trade. These are only "moderate" ideas in that most people already know they're the right way to go- but this is exactly what Conservatives have been screaming for for more than 20 years. If the media suddenly calls these stances "moderate," then they're calling many core Conservative values "Moderate." Considering the media's solid successes in making it okay only to vote for "moderate" Republicans, they're tacitly saying, "It's okay to vote for core Conservative values."
It fails even worse on foreign policy. The speech Mr. Romney gave today was incredible, from the transcript. The same ideas that won the peace after World War II and eventually brought down the "Evil Empire" of the Soviet Union were the foundation on which Mr. Romney built that speech. Without using the words, he nevertheless spoke of Peace through Strength. He spoke of the same "firewall" strategy we used to combat the spread, and eventually reverse the tide, of Communism. He spoke of foreign aid as a diplomatic weapon. He spoke of free trade as being valuable both economically and diplomatically. He spoke of supporting those who support our values.
Look at those points. If those are "Moderate" then every Republican since Ford has been a "Moderate." By calling those ideals he espoused "moderate," they are paving the way for another mass migration of Democrats- those blue collar Democrats who vote that way because that's just "what we do," to vote Republican in large numbers for the first time since they voted for Reagan.
And, yet, they're correct. For all this will hurt Democrats, the media is correct. These are moderate views. They are not some insane protectionist trite. They are not the views of some rabid war-monger. Economically they are not the views of some bleeding-heart, money-is-no-object Liberal and they are not the views of some, "Government is Evil!" weirdo. They are common sense ideas. They are ideas people know lead to prosperity, just they know the foreign policy ideas will lead to peace.
If it weren't so serious, it would be funny.
As it is, I believe I see what they're trying to do, but I think they're going to regret the tactic. The plan seems to be an attempt to drive a wedge between the conservative base and Mr. Romney. One of the biggest criticism of Romney during the primaries, and I certainly believed it, was that he was a "North Eastern Squish." That is, that he was too moderate.
Here is why that fails, however. Romney's performance in the Debate was many people's first introduction. In the debate, he was not "moderate." His answers were fairly orthodox conservatism. Lower taxes. Lower spending. Less regulation. More free trade. These are only "moderate" ideas in that most people already know they're the right way to go- but this is exactly what Conservatives have been screaming for for more than 20 years. If the media suddenly calls these stances "moderate," then they're calling many core Conservative values "Moderate." Considering the media's solid successes in making it okay only to vote for "moderate" Republicans, they're tacitly saying, "It's okay to vote for core Conservative values."
It fails even worse on foreign policy. The speech Mr. Romney gave today was incredible, from the transcript. The same ideas that won the peace after World War II and eventually brought down the "Evil Empire" of the Soviet Union were the foundation on which Mr. Romney built that speech. Without using the words, he nevertheless spoke of Peace through Strength. He spoke of the same "firewall" strategy we used to combat the spread, and eventually reverse the tide, of Communism. He spoke of foreign aid as a diplomatic weapon. He spoke of free trade as being valuable both economically and diplomatically. He spoke of supporting those who support our values.
Look at those points. If those are "Moderate" then every Republican since Ford has been a "Moderate." By calling those ideals he espoused "moderate," they are paving the way for another mass migration of Democrats- those blue collar Democrats who vote that way because that's just "what we do," to vote Republican in large numbers for the first time since they voted for Reagan.
And, yet, they're correct. For all this will hurt Democrats, the media is correct. These are moderate views. They are not some insane protectionist trite. They are not the views of some rabid war-monger. Economically they are not the views of some bleeding-heart, money-is-no-object Liberal and they are not the views of some, "Government is Evil!" weirdo. They are common sense ideas. They are ideas people know lead to prosperity, just they know the foreign policy ideas will lead to peace.
Friday, October 5, 2012
Barack Obama - Hypocrite
In Wednesday's debate, President Obama said this: "And so budgets reflect choices." Indeed, this has been a liberal talking point- that Mr. Romney's budget somehow shows he doesn't care for the poor. Now, this falls flat on several levels.
First, it fails on a personal level. Mitt Romney routinely gives 20 - 30% of his income to charities. Those are hardly the actions of someone who "doesn't care." By contrast, Barack Obama's donations to charities have been around 10%, and that only since he was elected President. Before that, he averaged in the single digits. The Bidens are even more tight fisted.
Second, it fails on a policy level. Mitt Romney has proposed a budget. It is a budget designed to get us back to a balanced budget... eventually. Barack Obama's proposed budget projected trillion dollar deficits for the foreseeable future. When you're willing to spend my grandchildren's money, there's a lot of things you can do for "the poor" that you can't when you're trying not to burden future generations with our profligate spending. One of those approaches is caring, the other is simply pandering. I'll let you decide which is which.
Moreover, President Obama's proposed budgets have not gotten more than a handful of votes between them in either the House or the Senate. These haven't been "party line votes." They have been mass repudiations of the President's budgets. Proposing a budget you know won't pass, and which garners a single digit of votes between the two houses, is functionally the same as not proposing a budget at all.
This charge is rank hypocrisy of the worst kind. It is a cynical and dishonest attack.
Finally (for this piece, at least), the attack fails on a moral level. Republicans detest poverty, but we love the impoverished. We hate poverty so much we want there to be less of it. There's an old saying that, "If you want more of something, subsidize it." Well, that's exactly what our government is doing right now with poverty- we are subsidizing the poor. Republicans are not advocating a complete abandonment of the impoverished. We are saying that the Federal Government is particularly poorly suited to helping the poor. The simple size and scope of the Federal Bureaucracy makes the administration of any but the very most straight forward welfare programs untenable. That's a purely practical consideration. More important is that the Constitution does not give the Federal Government the power to do anything about the poor at all.
So here is the summary of the Republican proposals for the poor: Send the duties, as much as is practical, back to the States. The States will be much more efficient at handling these programs. Reduce regulation and taxation to grow the economy, this will allow more jobs to be created and increase wages naturally. These are not policies which harm the poor, but help them. Specifically they are policies which help lift them out of poverty, instead of simply subsidizing their poverty and increasing their dependence.
First, it fails on a personal level. Mitt Romney routinely gives 20 - 30% of his income to charities. Those are hardly the actions of someone who "doesn't care." By contrast, Barack Obama's donations to charities have been around 10%, and that only since he was elected President. Before that, he averaged in the single digits. The Bidens are even more tight fisted.
Second, it fails on a policy level. Mitt Romney has proposed a budget. It is a budget designed to get us back to a balanced budget... eventually. Barack Obama's proposed budget projected trillion dollar deficits for the foreseeable future. When you're willing to spend my grandchildren's money, there's a lot of things you can do for "the poor" that you can't when you're trying not to burden future generations with our profligate spending. One of those approaches is caring, the other is simply pandering. I'll let you decide which is which.
Moreover, President Obama's proposed budgets have not gotten more than a handful of votes between them in either the House or the Senate. These haven't been "party line votes." They have been mass repudiations of the President's budgets. Proposing a budget you know won't pass, and which garners a single digit of votes between the two houses, is functionally the same as not proposing a budget at all.
This charge is rank hypocrisy of the worst kind. It is a cynical and dishonest attack.
Finally (for this piece, at least), the attack fails on a moral level. Republicans detest poverty, but we love the impoverished. We hate poverty so much we want there to be less of it. There's an old saying that, "If you want more of something, subsidize it." Well, that's exactly what our government is doing right now with poverty- we are subsidizing the poor. Republicans are not advocating a complete abandonment of the impoverished. We are saying that the Federal Government is particularly poorly suited to helping the poor. The simple size and scope of the Federal Bureaucracy makes the administration of any but the very most straight forward welfare programs untenable. That's a purely practical consideration. More important is that the Constitution does not give the Federal Government the power to do anything about the poor at all.
So here is the summary of the Republican proposals for the poor: Send the duties, as much as is practical, back to the States. The States will be much more efficient at handling these programs. Reduce regulation and taxation to grow the economy, this will allow more jobs to be created and increase wages naturally. These are not policies which harm the poor, but help them. Specifically they are policies which help lift them out of poverty, instead of simply subsidizing their poverty and increasing their dependence.
Thursday, October 4, 2012
Why Such A Failure?
The Real Reason Obama Fell Flat
By now, the Liberals' spin has gone from weak, to desperate, to sad, to delusional. The current spin is that "That's wasn't the real Mitt Romney." Excuse me, but my Irony meter just broke.But let's set that aside. Obama wasn't bad because of lies. He wasn't bad because Jim Lehrer wasn't a good moderator (he wasn't, but that was actually a point in Obama's favor). He wasn't bad because of high altitude, or because he was distracted, or because he was tired. Obama was bad for three reasons.
Reason 1: He's a SCOAMT. QED.
Reason 2: a) Facts b) Math.
The real reason, though, well beyond the other two, is that Liberals give Conservatives no credit for thought. They project their own emotional responses on us, and expect that we're BSing just as much as they are. Liberals just don't understand Conservative positions. So when he chose John Kerry to represent Mitt Romney in his debate prep, he really thought he was picking the best possible choice. Unfortunately for him, John Kerry has virtually nothing in common with Romney. Given this, and the fact that Kerry probably has never bothered to try to understand what Conservatives believe, he was sorely unprepared.
The flip side of that, however, is that Conservatives do tend to understand Liberal positions. So when Mitt Romney was preparing, that preparation was against someone who had bothered to understand the other side, and had really tried to represent the oppositions positions.
This combination meant that Romney was well prepared and ready for lines of attack, if not for specific soundbites, but Barack Obama was not. Obama came in prepared to fight the caricature of Romney that the Liberals had constructed. Indeed, he believes that's the "Real" Mitt Romney, and that the guy who showed up last night was some simulacrum.
As far as I'm concerned, they can keep believing that. It should make the next smack-down even more epic.
Jim Lehrer: Debate Opponent
Mitt Romney did not have one debate opponent last night, he had two. The first, of course, was Barack Obama, noted stuttering clusterf*ck of a miserable tyrant. The other was supposed "moderator" Jim Lehrer from that bastion of conservatism (sorry if your sarcasm meters just broke) PBS.
Let's take a look.
It began early. After Romney's opening 2 minutes, Lehrer addressed Obama:
Then as the first segment came to a close was this exchange:
Again, what? "Mr. Obama started this thing, so I think I should get the last word." "No, we're going to let him have the last word, because you get the first in the next segment." Huh? That would be like saying a baseball team doesn't get their last at-bat in the last home game of a series because they'll get the first at-bat in their next (away) game. What does the next segment have to do with this one?
Later, talking about taxes and the deficit, we get this exchange:
Does that sound like a "moderator" or a debate opponent hoping to get in a "gotcha" attack? Simpson-Bowles was not Romney's plan. He was not part of that panel. He had no say on it at all. Here's the thing, Lehrer was trying to ask, "Mr. Romney, when did you stop beating your wife?" If Romney simply says, "No" then Lehrer or the SCOAMT can jump all over the fact that Simpson-Bowles was "bipartisan." If he says, "Yes" they can try to drive a wedge between Romney and his Republican Base. If he tries to provide an accurate, clear answer, he's accused of (as here) evading the question or prevaricating.
Then, still talking about taxes and the deficit:
Then, on to health care:
Now this one is fairly subtle, and would be forgivable if he hadn't set himself in a position antagonistic to Mr. Romney. As it is, however, note the gratuitous (or, at least, almost gratuitous) use of the name "Affordable Care Act." Why "gratuitous?" Well, for one thing, he'd already called it ObamaCare previously. Indeed, Mr. Obama had embraced the term "ObamaCare" earlier in the debate saying "I like it," when referring to the term. The point was to get that word "Affordable" out there. "Mr. Romney, you want to repeal affordable health care," is the idea here.
Here's one, still talking about health care, where the SCOAMT finishes a statement, notice how Lehrer wants to let Mr. Obama get the last word in:
Then they turn to the roll of the Federal Government. After opening statements, Lehrer turns the discussion to education:
Quick aside here- notice that it's not "the roll of the Federal Government" to Lehrer- there is no difference to him between Federal, State, and Local government. Other than that, which is positively benign compared to the rest, that's a fairly balanced question. Romney answers- basically saying "Way reduced from where it is today" and Lehrer responds:
Now we've gone from "Is there a responsibility" to "there is a responsibility, because I'm the moderator and I say so." Again, this is not the behavior of a neutral "moderator" but an opponent.
Now, the spin today from many in the media is that Jim Lehrer is to blame for Mr. Obama's poor performance. That just doesn't hold up to the facts. First, Mr. Obama spoke for a full 4 minutes longer than Mr. Romney, so you can't say Lehrer was preferential to Mr. Romney there. And, as shown here, the nature of the questions and his support of the President's positions were designed to assist the President. Mr. Lehrer was not an objective moderator, he was a partisan shill for the President.
At Mitt Romney still beat both of them.
Update: Via JWF, the Democrats have an add where they try to say Romney "just kept going and going" suggesting that Romney won because he was mean to Jim Lehrer. I don't think that's going to fly, given that Jim Lehrer was actively on Obama's Side- as has been demonstrated.
Let's take a look.
It began early. After Romney's opening 2 minutes, Lehrer addressed Obama:
LEHRER: Mr. President, please respond directly to what the governor just said about trickle-down -- his trick-down approach, as he said yours is.Wait, what? "Mr. President, here's a line of attack you can use, please use it."
Then as the first segment came to a close was this exchange:
ROMNEY: Jim, the president began this segment, so I think I get the last word.
(CROSSTALK)
LEHRER: Well, you're going to get the first word in the next segment.
Again, what? "Mr. Obama started this thing, so I think I should get the last word." "No, we're going to let him have the last word, because you get the first in the next segment." Huh? That would be like saying a baseball team doesn't get their last at-bat in the last home game of a series because they'll get the first at-bat in their next (away) game. What does the next segment have to do with this one?
Later, talking about taxes and the deficit, we get this exchange:
LEHRER: Governor, what about Simpson-Bowles? Do you support Simpson-Bowles?
ROMNEY: Simpson-Bowles, the president should have grabbed that.
LEHRER: No, I mean, do you support Simpson-Bowles?
Does that sound like a "moderator" or a debate opponent hoping to get in a "gotcha" attack? Simpson-Bowles was not Romney's plan. He was not part of that panel. He had no say on it at all. Here's the thing, Lehrer was trying to ask, "Mr. Romney, when did you stop beating your wife?" If Romney simply says, "No" then Lehrer or the SCOAMT can jump all over the fact that Simpson-Bowles was "bipartisan." If he says, "Yes" they can try to drive a wedge between Romney and his Republican Base. If he tries to provide an accurate, clear answer, he's accused of (as here) evading the question or prevaricating.
Then, still talking about taxes and the deficit:
LEHRER: But -- but Mr. President, you're saying in order to -- to get the job done, it's got to be balanced. You've got to have...
Again, is that a moderator? It doesn't sound like a moderator to me, it sounds like someone who has taken sides. "Here, Mr. President, is your talking point..."
Then, on to health care:
LEHRER: You want it repealed. You want the Affordable Care Act repealed. Why?
Now this one is fairly subtle, and would be forgivable if he hadn't set himself in a position antagonistic to Mr. Romney. As it is, however, note the gratuitous (or, at least, almost gratuitous) use of the name "Affordable Care Act." Why "gratuitous?" Well, for one thing, he'd already called it ObamaCare previously. Indeed, Mr. Obama had embraced the term "ObamaCare" earlier in the debate saying "I like it," when referring to the term. The point was to get that word "Affordable" out there. "Mr. Romney, you want to repeal affordable health care," is the idea here.
Here's one, still talking about health care, where the SCOAMT finishes a statement, notice how Lehrer wants to let Mr. Obama get the last word in:
No. The reason is, is because, when we reform Wall Street, when we tackle the problem of pre-existing conditions, then, you know, these are tough problems and we've got to make choices. And the choices we've made have been ones that ultimately are benefiting middle-class families all across the country.
LEHRER: We're going to move to...
ROMNEY: No. I -- I have to respond to that.
LEHRER: No, but...
Then they turn to the roll of the Federal Government. After opening statements, Lehrer turns the discussion to education:
LEHRER: All right. Let's go through some specifics in terms of what -- how each of you views the role of government. How do -- education. Does the federal government have a responsibility to improve the quality of public education in America?
Quick aside here- notice that it's not "the roll of the Federal Government" to Lehrer- there is no difference to him between Federal, State, and Local government. Other than that, which is positively benign compared to the rest, that's a fairly balanced question. Romney answers- basically saying "Way reduced from where it is today" and Lehrer responds:
LEHRER: How do you see the federal government's responsibility to, as I say, to improve the quality of public education in this country?
Now we've gone from "Is there a responsibility" to "there is a responsibility, because I'm the moderator and I say so." Again, this is not the behavior of a neutral "moderator" but an opponent.
Now, the spin today from many in the media is that Jim Lehrer is to blame for Mr. Obama's poor performance. That just doesn't hold up to the facts. First, Mr. Obama spoke for a full 4 minutes longer than Mr. Romney, so you can't say Lehrer was preferential to Mr. Romney there. And, as shown here, the nature of the questions and his support of the President's positions were designed to assist the President. Mr. Lehrer was not an objective moderator, he was a partisan shill for the President.
At Mitt Romney still beat both of them.
Update: Via JWF, the Democrats have an add where they try to say Romney "just kept going and going" suggesting that Romney won because he was mean to Jim Lehrer. I don't think that's going to fly, given that Jim Lehrer was actively on Obama's Side- as has been demonstrated.
Mitt Romney: Tenther?
In last night's presidential debate, Mitt Romney seemed like a full-on Tenther. Who'd have thought I'd ever type that? But, nevertheless, it's there:
On helping the Middle Class:
On ObamaCare:
On the Role of Government:
On Education:
And back on Health Care:
This is not the Mitt Romney I expected.
Don't get me wrong. He was saying the same things to Republicans during the Primaries, and I acknowledge that (however grudgingly). But two things there: one, when talking about the role of the Federal Government versus the States during the primaries, it was where he seemed least comfortable. I don't know if it's because of practice, or just in comparison, but last night he seemed very comfortable and sure of what he was saying. Second, in the Primaries, he was running for Republicans- it's just the thing you say to Republicans if you want to win the Primary.
Last night, he could have let off the gas on the Federalism talk. He didn't have to talk about "the primary responsibility for education" being "at the state and local level." He could have simply acknowledged that the Federal Government can't do it alone, or some-such. That would have been "good enough" for many republicans, and would have been nice and safe for the moderates. He didn't have to mention the 10th Amendment explicitly, but he did. Many Americans don't even know what the 10th Amendment is.
Perhaps the most telling thing, because this is forgotten even by some Tenthers, is that he mentioned the People's rights. Let's look at the 10th again:
Now let's look at what Romney said about the roll of government: "...what we're seeing right now is ... a trickle-down government approach, which has the government thinking it can do a better job than free people pursuing their dreams."
Mitt Romney obviously gets it much better than I thought. Again, anyone could say these things, but to say them as smoothly and surely as he did? When he had, in essence, two debate opponents? To do that, he has to believe it- at least at some level.
Whether he knows it or not, Mitt Romney is a Tenther.
On helping the Middle Class:
"But the president mentioned a couple of other ideas I'll just note. First, education. I agree: Education is key, particularly the future of our economy. But our training programs right now, we've got 47 of them, housed in the federal government, reporting to eight different agencies. Overhead is overwhelming. We've got to get those dollars back to the states and go to the workers so they can create their own pathways to get in the training they need for jobs that will really help them."
On ObamaCare:
"The federal government taking over health care for the entire nation and whisking aside the 10th Amendment, which gives states the rights for these kinds of things, is not the course for America to have a stronger, more vibrant economy."
On the Role of Government:
"But we also believe in maintaining for individuals the right to pursue their dreams and not to have the government substitute itself for the rights of free individuals. And what we're seeing right now is, in my view, a -- a trickle-down government approach, which has government thinking it can do a better job than free people pursuing their dreams. And it's not working."
On Education:
"Well, the primary responsibility for education is -- is, of course, at the state and local level."
And back on Health Care:
"We'll put in place the kind of principles that I put in place in my own state and allow each state to craft their own programs to get people insured and we'll focus on getting the cost of health care down."
This is not the Mitt Romney I expected.
Don't get me wrong. He was saying the same things to Republicans during the Primaries, and I acknowledge that (however grudgingly). But two things there: one, when talking about the role of the Federal Government versus the States during the primaries, it was where he seemed least comfortable. I don't know if it's because of practice, or just in comparison, but last night he seemed very comfortable and sure of what he was saying. Second, in the Primaries, he was running for Republicans- it's just the thing you say to Republicans if you want to win the Primary.
Last night, he could have let off the gas on the Federalism talk. He didn't have to talk about "the primary responsibility for education" being "at the state and local level." He could have simply acknowledged that the Federal Government can't do it alone, or some-such. That would have been "good enough" for many republicans, and would have been nice and safe for the moderates. He didn't have to mention the 10th Amendment explicitly, but he did. Many Americans don't even know what the 10th Amendment is.
Perhaps the most telling thing, because this is forgotten even by some Tenthers, is that he mentioned the People's rights. Let's look at the 10th again:
"The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."
Now let's look at what Romney said about the roll of government: "...what we're seeing right now is ... a trickle-down government approach, which has the government thinking it can do a better job than free people pursuing their dreams."
Mitt Romney obviously gets it much better than I thought. Again, anyone could say these things, but to say them as smoothly and surely as he did? When he had, in essence, two debate opponents? To do that, he has to believe it- at least at some level.
Whether he knows it or not, Mitt Romney is a Tenther.
Barack Obama: Stuttering Fustercluck of a Miserable Failure
I'll have a couple of longer posts about last night's debate later. I didn't get to watch it live, but I have read the transcript and it was a class 'A' shellacking.
Mitt Romney seemed well prepared and at ease. Of course, this is easier to do when the facts are on your side, as they were for Mitt Romney. Barack Obama was... well, a stuttering clusterf*ck of a miserable failure. He couldn't give even the most basic defense of any of his policies. At one point he asked the moderator to save him by changing the topic.
And the whole time Mitt Romney stuck deep, barbed rhetorical spears into his opponent.
A couple of choice quotes:
If the next two presidential debates are anything like this one, I expect Mr. Obama is in for some long, sleepless nights.
Mitt Romney seemed well prepared and at ease. Of course, this is easier to do when the facts are on your side, as they were for Mitt Romney. Barack Obama was... well, a stuttering clusterf*ck of a miserable failure. He couldn't give even the most basic defense of any of his policies. At one point he asked the moderator to save him by changing the topic.
And the whole time Mitt Romney stuck deep, barbed rhetorical spears into his opponent.
A couple of choice quotes:
"I know that you and your running mate keep saying that and I know it's a popular thing to say with a lot of people, but it's just not the case. Look, I've got five boys. I'm used to people saying something that's not always true, but just keep on repeating it and ultimately hoping I'll believe it."
"Mr. President, you're entitled as the president to your own airplane and to your own house, but not to your own facts."
If the next two presidential debates are anything like this one, I expect Mr. Obama is in for some long, sleepless nights.
Monday, October 1, 2012
An Early Morning Pick-Me-Up
If you haven't read Mitt Romney's Op-Ed in the Wall Street Journal, do yourself a favor and do so.
The one place I have been unsure of Mitt's direction is foreign policy, and this gives a very good indication of his plans.
The one place I have been unsure of Mitt's direction is foreign policy, and this gives a very good indication of his plans.
- Restore our close ties with Israel
- Strengthen our Economy at home to give strength to our economic "Soft Power" abroad
- Strengthen our Military to pursue "Peace through Strength"
- Defend our Values (*ahem*Free Speech*ahem*) at home and abroad
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)